Syntax
Literate: Jurnal Ilmiah Indonesia p�ISSN: 2541-0849
e-ISSN:
2548-1398
Vol.
5, No. 8, Agustus 2020
�
DOMINANCE
OF MARKET SHARE OF SUKUK IN INDONESIA
Dini
Selasi
Ma'had Ali Islamic
College of Religion Cirebon (STAIMA) Cirebon, Indonesia
Email: [email protected]
Abstract
Indonesia is one
of the issuers of sukuk in the world with various series that have been issued,
this sukuk aims to help finance the state budget for various sectors for
sustainable development programs. This study uses a qualitative research
method using a phenomenological approach. The results show that the
government is still dominated by sukuk because most of the financing of sukuk
in Indonesia are government projects in various sectors, in
their issuance in collaboration with conventional and sharia banking,
securities companies that become AB Bursa. Sukuk series issued by the
government such as Islamic Fixed Rate (IFR), greensukuk,
Indonesian hajj fund sukuk (SDHI), savings sukuk, retail sukuk, sharia state
treasury bills (SPNS), project based sukuk (PBS).
Keywords:
sukuk, market share, dominance
Introduction
In Islam, this endeavor is obligatory
because it is an effort to make our lives better in all fields, including investment. Investment
as a form of our efforts as humans to make economic life better because the
assets we have must have zakat so that our assets are not consumed by zakat as
in the letter At Taubah: 103 "Take zakat from some of their assets, with
that zakat you clean. and sanctify them " (Ministry of Religion of the Republic of Indonesia,
2015) . Investment
is a form of implementing the use of assets for productive activities, the more
productive, the greater the zakat, but the wheels of the economy will be
better (Hidayat, 2011). In
simple terms, zakat can still be paid as a cleansing of our assets which can be
taken from the investment profits we get.
In Islam, all aspects of life are regulated
in the Qur'an and Hadith, including investments in accordance with the
sharia. There are several things that are not allowed in investment
activities, namely maisir, gharar, usury, batil, bay'i ma'dium,
ihtikar, taghrir, ghabn, talaqqi al-rukban, ghishsh, tanajush / najsh, dharar,
rishwah, immorality and zalim (DSN-MUI., 2019). In
addition, investment must be professional, starting from the type of business,
the person or entity that manages it so that the investment can provide
benefits for both (Putra, 2018). There are many types of investment
that can be channeled for the development of our assets, many types of
investment in the Islamic capital market, namely Islamic stocks, sukuk, Islamic
mutual funds, Islamic exchange traded funds (ETF), sharia
asset-backed securities (EBA), sharia real estate investment funds (DIRE) (IDX Islamic, n.d.).
Sukuk investment in Indonesia is starting
to be of interest to the public at large because it does not require large
capital, the same as other types of investment in the Islamic capital market,
sukuk is a type of securitization of assets in accordance with Islamic
principles in the Islamic capital market (IDX Islamic, n.d.). Indonesia
is a large country with a very large population so that Indonesia is a very
potential market for various types of world investment, many world investors
are interested in investing their capital.
Sukuk are starting to be of interest to
the public in Indonesia with a very encouraging development, there are many
sharia effects that can be used as an alternative investment in the Islamic
capital market and sukuk are an alternative investment in
Indonesia. However, the existence of sukuk is still dominated by the
Government in its issuance in accordance with Law number 19 of 2008 concerning
sukuk (Bank Indonesia, 2018) which
is intended for government-owned infrastructure where the sukuk is a
development financing that involves community participation.
In this study we will focus on the sukuk
or state sharia-based letter (SBSN) in Indonesia, This research focuses on the development of sukuk issued
by the Indonesian government and the extent of the government's dominance in
issuing these sukuk and how the impact is generated by the issuance of
government sukuk, the implementation of sukuk financing for infrastructure
development in Indonesia and the development of the sukuk itself for
development in Indonesia. If
in the previous research only explained some types of sukuk, for example only
savings sukuk or retail sukuk, but in this study it explains all types of sukuk
issued by the government both to domestic investors and investors abroad with
various types of sukuk, so
it can be seen how the government dominates in issuing sukuk.
�
Method
This study uses a qualitative research
method with a phenomenological approach, which significant statements,
structural and textual descriptions, data sources are carried out by
interviews, using documents, observation and art by trying to explain
rationally, using assumptions and supporting data related to it . with this
research (Creswell & Clark, 2017). This study uses a qualitative research
method with a phenomenological approach, data sources used are data from various
agencies such as the roadmap for the Indonesian Islamic capital market, the
internet, books on the Islamic capital market, especially about sukuk in
general, statistical data so that it describes important statements and is able
to describe. the development that occurred was the development of sukuk in
Indonesia. Interviews in this study use a virtual system such as in the Islamic
capital market webinars such as the head of the Islamic capital market
division, members of the national sharia board (DSN). Observations were made by
looking at the number and types of sukuk in Indonesia that were getting better,
especially among stock investors who were starting to be interested in
increasing their investment in sukuk through several groups on social media
such as WhatsApp, Instagram, Telegram and others.
Results And Discussion
Government policy to develop the Islamic
financial market in Indonesia, the Government seeks to launch a sharia-based
investment and financing instrument, namely State Sharia Securities (SBSN) or
known as State Sukuk. The SBSN Law is a breath of fresh air for both the
Government and market players in their efforts to develop domestic financial
markets. So far, sukuk has developed conducive to economic development and
stimulates investment development and has a positive effect on economic
growth (Smaoui & Khawaja, 2017).
The community is already familiar with
investment activities, especially investments in the Islamic capital market,
sukuk is one of the investment alternatives where Indonesia is not the first
country to issue sukuk but Malaysia, which was issued in 2019 in the form of
corporate sukuk, while the country's first issuing sukuk is
country. Bahrain in 2001, meanwhile in Indonesia, the first to publish was
PT. Indosat Tbk in the form of corporate sukuk in 2002 (Aminy, 2018).
The issuance of Indonesian sukuk is not
only intended for the domestic market but for the international market as well
as in 2009 the government issued Indonesian State Sukuk (SNI) or also known as
Indonesian global sukuk, when the SNI 25 series sukuk in 2015 was issued sukuk
on the international market this shows that the sukuk can be accepted by the
international community, here is the distribution (Hariyanto, 2015).
Table 3. Distribution of Sukuk
with International Investors
Spread
of Investor Countries |
Number
(%) |
the
middle East |
41% |
Europe |
16% |
United
States of America |
21% |
Asia |
12% |
Indonesia |
10% |
Source: (Hariyanto, 2015)
The journey of issuing sukuk in Indonesia
is not the first time in the world, but since its inaugural issuance to date it
has in extraordinary developments, here is the journey of state sukuk from 2008
to 2016 (Finance., n.d.)starting
from the issuance of Law No. 19 year 2008 concerning State Sharia Securities or
SBSN.
Figure 1. State Sukuk Milestone 2008-2016
Source:
(Finance., n.d.)
Indonesia is one of the issuers of sukuk
in the world, the first issuance of sukuk in Indonesia in 2004, namely sukuk
with an ijarah contract with a value of Rp. 4.7
trillion which continues to grow from year to year, here is the development of
sukuk in Indonesia (Ardi, 2018):
Table 4. Development of Sukuk in Indonesia
Year |
Sukuk |
2004 |
The value of the sukuk with
an ijarah contract with a value of Rp. 4.7
trillion |
2005 |
Issued by 3 companies that issue
sukuk ijarah |
2006 |
Issued by 1 company to issue
sukuk ijarah |
2007 |
Issued 3 sukuk ijarah and
1 sukuk with a mudharabah agreement |
2008 |
Issued 2 sukuk mudharabah ,
4 sukuk ijarah , 2 SBSN |
2009 |
Issued 14 sukuk ijarah with
6 SBSNs |
2010 |
Issuing sukuk ijarah,
mudharabah respectively 1. |
2011 |
Issued 1 sukuk mudharabah |
2012 |
The value of the sukuk ijarah
is Rp. 57.09 trillion |
2014 |
The increase in value in 2014 was
75.54 trillion |
Source: (Ardi, 2018)
Since the issuance of state sharia
securities (SBSN) for the first time in 2008 it has experienced a tremendous
increase even in 2014 it experienced excess demand which in lowering the profit
sharing that must be given to investors, sukuk in Indonesia is intended for
development financing, government project financing can help the Indonesian
economy besides sukuk as an alternative to halal investment for Muslims (Indriasari, 2018),
sukuk as a new form of investment in Indonesia with a lot of interest from
domestic investors which is marked by the value of sukuk which continues to
increase from year to year.
The purpose of issuing state sharia
securities (SBSN) is to finance the state revenue and expenditure budget and to
build government projects based on sharia principles using ijarah,
mudharabah, musyarakah, istisna 'contracts issued directly by the
government or through SBSN issuing companies in accordance with the
provisions; has assets in the form of land and buildings (President of the Republic of Indonesia, 2008). The
projects to be launched in the 2020 fiscal year are 728 projects spread across
34 provinces, as follows (Finance., n.d.):
1.
A total of 30
transportation infrastructure projects at the Ministry of Transportation with a
value of Rp.6.90 trillion;
2.
A total of 171 road and
bridge infrastructure projects at the Directorate General of Highways at the
PUPR Ministry with a financing value of Rp.10.60 trillion;
3.
A total of 66
infrastructure projects for flood and lahar control, management of dams and
reservoirs, as well as management of main urban drainage at the Directorate
General of Natural Resources at the Ministry of PUPR with a financing value of
Rp.4.50 trillion;
4.
A total of 10 haj
embarkation projects and 40 integrated haj service center projects at the
Directorate General of PHU of the Ministry of Religion, valued at Rp.460
billion;
5.
A total of 6
constructions of PTKIN building facilities and facilities and 136 madrasas at
the Directorate General of Islamic Education at the Ministry of Religion,
valued at IDR 2.09 trillion;
6.
A total of 228
construction and rehabilitation projects for marriage halls and Hajj rituals at
the Directorate General of Islamic Community Guidance at the Ministry of
Religion, valued at IDR 356.25 billion;
7.
There are 6 conservation
center development projects, 1 state forestry secondary school construction
project and 2 laboratory construction at the Ministry of LHK worth IDR 237.41
billion;
8.
A total of 24 higher
education building construction projects at the Ministry of Research,
Technology and Higher Education worth Rp1.49 trillion;
9.
A total of 1 laboratory
development project in BSN is worth IDR 70 billion;
10.
A total of 4 laboratory
development projects at LIPI worth IDR 500 billion; and
11.
There is a total of 1
peseta component testing laboratory project at LAPAN valued at IDR 125 billion.
Sukuk must have clear underlying or
assets, project-based sukuk are commonly used for developing countries with
assets that can contribute 62% with the support of 19% of assets from global
sukuk then based on the criteria for the return type of sukuk based on assets
98% from global suskuk with supporting assets. of 2% (Sillah, 2018). In
the issuance of sukuk, there are several things that can affect it, such as
company profits and then always adhering to sharia rules for the type of
sukuk mudharabah issuance , other factors are the sukuk
yield as well as the inflation rate and the age of the sukuk issuing
company (Utami, Trinugroho, & Sergi, 2019).
Countries that issue sukuk will provide
returns to the public as investors if the GDP (Gross Domestic Product) of a
country is high which is marked by high tax revenues, the government can pay
higher returns on the sukuk and vice versa, however, it must be noted that the
quality of the sukuk issued is not only the quantity only takes into account the
adaptation of the sukuk sharia law that is being traded (Hendri, 2018). Based
on the estimation results from Distributed Lag (ARDL) in the long term that
there is an exchange rate that has a significant effect on SBSN while inflation
and interest rates do not have a significant effect on SBSN so that SBSN is a
safe investment in accordance with sharia principles (Juaris, Masbar, & Seftarita, 2018).
National sharia securities or SBSN in
Indonesia are developing well as a financing instrument in helping the
government revenue budget as well as a factor in the development of the Islamic
financial industry, in the development of sukuk during 2008-2018 are as follows (Ministry of Finance, 2018).
1.
State sukuk has
experienced significant development according to data from the Ministry of
Finance, the total accumulated sukuk issuance up to October 2018 was IDR 950
trillion or equivalent to USD 63 billion, outsatanding as of October 25 was IDR
657 trillion, so that the contribution of sukuk to APBN financing was 30% of
the amount. tota of Government Securities (SBN) financing.
2.
Sukuk financing is
intended for project financing ( Project Financing Sukuk )
such as financing infrastructure development; roads, bridges, dams,
irrigation, groundwater management, national park development, schools and
development, laboratory construction. This financing has been implemented
from 2013 to 2018 in 34 provinces, which has reached IDR 62.4 trillion.
3.
Since the issuance of
regular sukuk in 2009, there has been tremendous development with the toral of
retail sukuk issuance reaching Rp. 144.7 trillion which can be enjoyed by
243,364 domestic investors. Meanwhile, the development of savings sukuk
that is favored by 11,338 investors has reached Rp. 2.6 trillion with an
average of Rp. 228 million per investor.
4.
Apart from retail sukuk,
Indonesia also issued sovereign green sukuk in 2018 which was
the first country in the world to issue this type of sukuk, besides that
Indonesia is also the largest international sovereign sukuk
issuer since 2009, this shows that Indonesia has shown support and
contributed to the world. for the development of domestic and
international Islamic finance.
5. Many
achievements have been obtained by the state sukuk with various international
awards such as;
a.
Alpha Southeast Asia;
b.
The Asset, Finance Asia;
c.
Credit Magazine;
d.
Asia Money;
e.
IFR Asia;
f.
Islamic Finance News;
g.
Euromoney Islamic Finance
Awards;
h.
Global Islamic Finance
Awards;
i.
Asia Pacific Green/SRI Bond Deal of the
Year ( Global Capital / Euromoney -September
2018)
State sharia securities (SBSN) or
sukuk are part of the issuance of sukuk in Indonesia, issued by the
government with the aim of assisting the State Budget (APBN) in the form of
government project financing, here are some developments from SBSN or sukuk in
Indonesia:
Islamic Fixed Rate (IFR)
Islamic
Fixed Rate or IFR is issued by the government with a term of more than 1 year
through auction, private placement , closed secondary market,
then investors will get a return every 6 months in rupiah currency (Ministry of Finance, 2016). Since
2008 and 2009 when it was published for the first time in the domestic market
by means of bookbuilding (ordering for a certain period by way
of auction) but after 2011 Islamic Fixed Rate (IFT) was no longer published
then a series of Project Based Sukuk (PBS) was issued instead. with a
system similar to that of IRT (Nopijantoro, 2018). There
are several developments that occurred in the development of national
securities, especially in the State Sharia Securities from 2014 to 2018 (Bank Indonesia, 2018) as
follows:
Table 5 Position of Government Securities
(SBN) in Billion Rupiah
Type of SBSN |
2014 |
2015 |
2016 |
2017 |
2018 |
2018 |
|||
June |
July |
Agust |
Sept |
||||||
Fixed
Rate |
0 |
0 |
201,917 |
292,544 |
349,458 |
377,409 |
393,859 |
405,639 |
417,639 |
Retail
SBSN |
47,906 |
56,257 |
72,788 |
67,502 |
53,974 |
43,591 |
43,591 |
43,591 |
43,591 |
Sharia
SPN |
10,735 |
14,099 |
7,700 |
19,640 |
25,250 |
28,760 |
26,310 |
24,660 |
25,310 |
Savings
Sukuk (ST) |
0 |
0 |
2,585 |
2,524 |
4,946 |
10,707 |
10,707 |
12,669 |
12,669 |
Source: (Bank Indonesia, 2018)
Retail Sukuk (SR)
State
Sharia Securities or SBSN issued by the government by means of bookbuilding ,
this series began to be issued in 2009 under the names SR-01 to SR-11 in 2019,
where they can be traded with fixed yields. The issuance of this retail
sukuk uses the Ijarah Sale and Lease Back contract using
state-owned goods (BMN) as the underlying, then the use of
another contract is Ijarah Asset to be Leased using state-owned
goods and projects ordered by the government as the underlying (Yaya & Sofiyana, 2018). Following
are some of the developments in retail sukuk in Indonesia.
Table 6 Types of Retail Sukuk and
Their Development
Series |
ISIN code |
Rewards Per Year |
Order Value Limit per Investor |
Number
of Agents |
Offer Period |
Date Vendor hold |
Date of issue |
Listing date on the Exchange |
Date
of maturity |
Time (Yrs) |
Total Issues |
Total
Investors |
|
Bank |
Exchange
Prshn |
||||||||||||
SR-001 |
IDJ000003009 |
12.00% |
|
5 |
8 |
30/1 -
20/2-2009 |
|
25/2/2009 |
26/2/2009 |
25/2/2012 |
3 yrs |
IDR
5,556,290,000,000 |
14,295 |
SR-002 |
IDP000000705 |
8.70% |
A multiple of IDR 5 million, with no
maximum limit |
10 |
8 |
25 / 1- 5 / 2-2010 |
8/2/2010 |
10 / 2/2010 |
11 / 2/2010 |
10/2/2013 |
3 yrs |
IDR 8,033,860,000,000 |
17,231 |
SR-003 |
IDJ000004601 |
8.15% |
A multiple of
IDR 5 million, with no maximum limit |
11 |
9 |
7 - 18/2 2011 |
21/2 2011 |
23/2 2011 |
24/2 2011 |
23 Feb 2014 |
3 years |
IDR
7,341,410,000,000 |
15,847 |
SR-004 |
IDJ000004809 |
6.25% |
A multiple of
IDR 5 million, a maximum of IDR 5 billion |
13 |
11 |
5 - 16 March
2012 |
19 Mar 2012 |
March 21, 2012 |
22 March 2012 |
21 Sept 2015 |
3.5 years |
IDR
13,613,805,000,000 |
17,606 |
SR-005 |
IDJ000005509 |
6.00% |
A multiple of
IDR 5 million, a maximum of IDR 5 billion |
16 |
9 |
8 - 22 Feb 2013 |
25 Feb 2013 |
27 Feb 2013 |
28 Feb 2013 |
27 Feb 2016 |
3 yrs |
IDR
14,968,875,000,000 |
17,783 |
SR-006 |
IDJ000006200 |
8.75% |
A multiple of
IDR 5 million, a maximum of IDR 5 billion |
19 |
9 |
Feb 14-28 2014 |
3 Mar 2014 |
March 5, 2014 |
March 6, 2014 |
March 5, 2017 |
3 yrs |
IDR
19,323,345,000,000 |
34,692 |
SR-007 |
IDJ000006705 |
8.25% |
A multiple of
IDR 5 million, a maximum of IDR 5 billion |
17 |
5 |
23 Feb- 6 March
2015 |
9Mar 2015 |
Wednesday, 11
Mar 2015 |
Thursday, 12
Mar 2015 |
March 11, 2018 |
3 years |
IDR
21,965,035,000,000 |
29,706 |
SR-008 |
IDJ000007505 |
8.30% |
A multiple of
IDR 5 million, a maximum of IDR 5 billion |
20 |
6 |
Friday, 19 Feb
- Friday, 4 March 2016 |
7 Mar 2016 |
Thursday, March
10 2016 |
Friday, March
11, 2016 |
March 10, 2019 |
3 years |
IDR
31,500,000,000,000 |
48,444 |
SR-009 |
IDJ000008503 |
6.90% |
A multiple of
IDR 5 million, a maximum of IDR 5 billion |
21 |
1 |
Monday, 27 Feb-
Friday, 17 March 2017 |
Monday, 20
March 2017 |
Wednesday March
22 2017 |
Thursday, 23
March 2017 |
March 10, 2020 |
3 years |
IDR
14,037,310,000,000 |
29,838 |
SR-010 |
IDJ000010400 |
5.90% |
A multiple of
IDR 5 million, a maximum of IDR 5 billion |
20 |
2 |
Friday, 23 Feb-
Friday, 16 March 2018 |
Monday, 19
March 2018 |
Wednesday, 21
March 2018 |
Thursday, 22
March 2018 |
March 10, 2021 |
3 yrs |
|
|
SR-012 |
|
6.30% |
Starting from 1
million |
17 |
5 |
24 Feb 2020 |
18 March 2020 |
March 26, 2020 |
|
March 10, 2023 |
3 yrs |
|
|
Source: http://kemenkeu.go.id/sukukritel
Retail
sukuk in Indonesia are in great demand by the domestic community as an
investment alternative, here are some projects that have been generated from
retail sukuk financing (Ministry of Finance, 2020), namely:
1.
The construction of Jalan
Gerung Mataram, NTB, was financed by the State Sukuk for the Year 2015
2.
Construction of the
Amplas Medan Flyover Ramp on / off, financed by the State Sukuk for the 2016
fiscal year.
3.
The construction of the
IAIN Salatiga Central Java lecture building, funded by the State Sukuk for the
2015-2016 academic year.
4.
Construction of the Solo
- Ngawi toll road section I - Colomadu Karanganyar, Central Java, financed by
the State Sukuk for the 2017-2018 academic year.
5.
The construction of the
UIN Manado North Sulawesi lecture building was funded by the State Sukuk for
the 2018 year.
6.
The construction of the
Cirebon-Kroya-Solo-Madiun-Jombang Java South Double Track Railway, was financed
by the State Sukuk for the 2013-2019 fiscal year.
7.
Construction of
the New Yogyakarta International Airport (NYIA) underpass in
Kulonprogo Regency, Yogyakarta Special Region (DIY). The cost required in
the construction of this underpass is IDR 293 billion which will be put into
operation on December 20, 2019.
8.
Makassar Hajj hostel
9.
Youtefa Bridge
(Holtekamp) - Papua.
10.
UIN Sunan Gunung Jati.
11.
Musi 4 Bridge Palembang
12.
Double-Doule Track of
Manggarai Train - Cikarang
13.
Notog Railway Tunnel -
Banyumas
Retail
sukuk issued by the Government also collaborates with distribution partners in
Indonesia from the national banking sector as well as from various securities
companies involved in the issuance of this sukuk (Government of the
Republic of Indonesia, 2020) are as follows
1.
PT Bank BRI Syariah, Tbk ;
2.
PT Bank Central Asia, Tbk
;
3.
PT Bank CIMB Niaga Tbk ;
4.
PT Bank DBS Indonesia ;
5.
PT Bank HSBC Indonesia;
6.
PT Bank Madiri (Persero),
Tbk;
7.
PT Bank Maubank Indonesia
;
8.
PT Bank Muamalat
Indonesia Tbk ;
9.
PT Bank Negara Indonesia
(Persero) Tbk;
10.
PT Bank Panin Tbk ;
11.
PT Bank Permata, Tbk ;
12.
PT Bank Rakyat Indonesia
(Persero) Tbk ;
13.
PT Bank Syariah Mandiri
.; PT Bank Tabungan Negara (Persero) Tbk :
14.
PT Baeksa Investment
Portal PT Danareksa Sekuritas.
15.
PT Investree Rahika Jaya.
16.
PT Mandiri Sekuritas.
17.
PT Mitrausaha Indonesia
Group.
18.
PT Nusantara Sejahtera
Investama.
19.
PT Trimgah Sekuritas
Indonesia,
20.
PT Star Mercato Capitale.
21.
PT Sinarmas Sekuritas.
22.
PT Bank Danamon
Indonesia, Tbk.
23.
PT Bahana Sekuritas,
24.
PT Bank Commonwealth.
25.
PT Bank UOB Indonesia.
Global
Sukuk or Indonesian State Sukuk (SNI)
Issued
by the government using the bookbuilding method in the
form of foreign currency, namely USD issued in 2009 with a tradable nature and
will get fixed returns. Based on research from Rahman (Rahman, Duasa, Kassim, & Zainudin, 2017), sukuk
published by the Government of Indonesia, Turkey, Malaysia, the United Arab
Emirates, Bahrain using panel data from 2006 to 2013 show that only the
inflation rate is able to influence the yield of the country's
sukuk. Other factors that influence the development of sukuk are
structural, financial and institutional factors, as well as the state's
macroeconomic condition in the period 2001 to 2013 in 13 countries (Smaoui & Khawaja, 2017). Sukuk
financing by the government is mostly for infrastructure financing with
procedures starting from project preparation, proposal, feasibility assessment,
fiscal considerations, approval and rejection, allocation of funds, preparation
for project implementation then funding for state sukuk, while the financing
structure is divided into project financing and project
underlying (Fauziah, Syifa, & Nurwahidin, 2020).
When
the global sukuk was first issued in 2009, it was already in demand by world
investors and even experienced an excess of demand, the yields given were also
much greater than that of the country sukuk issued domestically, the difference
is approximately 3-5% , this is one of the reasons factors of increasing demand
for global sukuk, according to Eri Haryanto as an employee of the Directorate
General of Financing and Risk Management of the Ministry of Finance of the
Republic of Indonesia (Hariyanto, 2017) with
the development of world investors, namely:
Table 7 �Development of Indonesian State Sukuk
Investors (SNI) SNI 25 series
Country |
total |
the middle East |
41% |
United States of America |
21% |
Europe |
16% |
Asia |
12% |
Indonesia |
10% |
Source: Ministry of Finance
Indonesia
issued global sukuk with SNI21 and SNI26 series, according to the Directorate
General of Financing and Risk Management that for the first time Indonesia
issued global sukuk in dual-tranche (Risk, 2016) the issuance
was carried out on March 21, 2016 and the settlement was carried out on March
29, 2016 which was listed on Singapore Stock Exchange and NASDAQ Dubai with the
following conditions:
1.
SNI21 series; 5-year
tenor, will mature on March 29, 2021 with a yield of 3.4%, with a nominal value
of US $ 750
2.
SNI26
series; 10-year tenor, will mature on March 29, 2026 with a yield of 4.55%
and a nominal value of US $ 1.75 billion.
3.
Both of them use sharia
principles with the wakalah contract also having
underlying assets in the form of State Property; land and buildings by 51%
and government projects by 49% which is the largest sukuk issuance in Asia.
In
general, sukuk is in demand by world investors, especially for non-Muslim
investors, this is because in Islam it focuses on openness or transparency so
that no one is harmed, is careful not to carry out speculative activities, by
sharing existing risks and the main thing. is not making investments that
contain usury, there is a clear underlying condition and Indonesia is an international sovereign sukuk issuing country with a total
of US $ 16.15 billion (Directorate of Sharia Financing, 2018)
Indonesian
Hajj Fund Sukuk (ADHI);
The contract used
by ijarah al khadamat is non-tradable in nature which is
a private placement which is a follow-up to the cooperation
with the Ministry of Finance and the Ministry of Religion in 2009 in accordance
with the DSN-MUI fatwa no.118 / DSN-MUI / 2009 with the underlying form
of haj services (lodging, food and transportation). The Indonesian Hajj
Fund Sukuk (SDHI) is very effective in financing because it can handle half of
the service needs and costs of Indonesian Hajj which are marked by an increase
in the quality of Hajj such as improvements to lodging or lodging, consumption
and transportation used by Indonesian pilgrims (Sianipar, 2019). On
November 4, 2015, the Directorate General of Risk and Financing Management of
the Ministry of Finance issued state sharia securities with the SDHI 2023 A
series (Directorate General of Financing and Risk Management,
2015) with several provisions,
as follows:
1.
Issued on November 4,
2015 and will mature on November 4, 2023.
2.
Nominal value of
Rp. 1,500,000,000,000.
3.
Yield of 8.82% per annum,
which is paid monthly (every 4th day).
4.
Payment of the first
yield on December 4, 2015 and payment of the last yield on November 4, 2023.
5.
Trade terms; not
tradable or non tradable.
6.
Using Al
Khadamat adad
7.
Underlying ; Services
8.
Issuer; Indonesian
SBSN issuing company.
In
2018 the Indonesian hajj fund sukuk or SDHI has reached 36.70 trillion, using
the Ijarah al khadamat agreement with the underlying Hajj
services with the issuer of the Indonesian SBSN issuing company, SDHI has
issued its sukuk since 2011 with various series as delivered in the 7
th IndonesiaX seminar Educational Conference: "Islamic
Economics and Finance: Present and Future" (Directorate of Sharia Financing,
2018) :
Table 8 SDHI Outstanding as of February
2018
No. |
Series |
Publishing |
Due date |
Rewards |
Amount (Rp) |
1. |
SDHI
2021A |
11-Apr-11 |
11-Apr-21 |
8.00% |
2,000,000,000,000 |
2. |
SDHI
2021B |
17-Oct-11 |
17-Oct-21 |
7.16% |
3,000,000,000,000 |
3. |
SDHI
2020E |
21-Mar-17 |
21-Mar-20 |
7.14% |
2,000,000,000,000 |
4. |
SDHI
2019A |
21-Mar-12 |
21-Mar-19 |
5.46% |
3,000,000,000,000 |
5. |
SDHI
2022A |
21-Mar-12 |
21-Mar-22 |
5.91% |
3,342,000,000,000 |
6. |
SDHI
2020A |
27-Apr-12 |
27-Apr-20 |
5.79% |
1,500,000,000,000 |
7. |
SDHI
2018A |
30-May-12 |
30-May-18 |
6.06% |
2,500,000,000,000 |
8. |
SDHI
2020B |
28-Jun-12 |
28-Jun-20 |
6.20% |
1,000,000,000,000 |
9. |
SDHI
2020C |
3-Jan-14 |
3-Jan-20 |
8.30% |
3,000,000,000,000 |
10. |
SDHI
2019B |
11-Feb-14 |
11-Feb-19 |
8.05% |
2,000,000,000,000 |
11. |
SDHI
2022B |
11-Feb-14 |
11-Feb-22 |
8.75% |
2,000,000,000,000 |
12. |
SDHI
2024A |
11-Feb-14 |
11-Feb-24 |
9.04% |
2,000,000,000,000 |
13. |
SDHI
2024A |
25-Mar-14 |
25-Mar-29 |
8.43% |
1,000,000,000,000 |
14. |
SDHI
2029B |
13-Aug-14 |
13-Aug-29 |
8.62% |
2,855,000,000,000 |
15. |
SDHI
2020D |
29-Jun-15 |
29-Jun-20 |
8.20% |
1,000,000,000,000 |
16. |
SDHI
2025A |
8-Jul-15 |
8-Jul-25 |
8.30% |
2,000,000,000,000 |
17. |
SDHI
2023A |
4-Nov-15 |
4-Nov-23 |
8.82% |
1,500,000,000,000 |
18. |
SDHI
2019C |
27-Apr-16 |
27-Apr-19 |
7.20% |
1,000,000,000,000 |
Total
Indonesian Hajj Fund Sukuk (SDHI) |
36,697,000,000,000 |
Sharia State Treasury Bills (SPNS)
Is
a short-term sukuk (tenor 6 months) with the aim of assisting the management of
the state treasury and the development of the Islamic money market. Sharia
State Treasury Bills (SPNS) are state sukuk that are traded through auctions
and private placements using the rupiah currency with a term
or tenor of 1 year with a discount in the form of a discount (Djppr, 2019). In
fact, the government sharia bonds or sukuk as a whole have a lower risk and
better performance than conventional state bonds, the focus of the instruments
studied from 2008 to 2016, such as the average interest rate of Bank Indonesia,
yield to maturity, current yield, global bond rating (Ulumuddin, 2016).
The
state sukuk with the SPNS series (Sharia State Treasury Bills) has conducted an
auction on April 7, 2020 in an effort to meet the 2020 APBN budgeting target,
the auction will be announced on the same day where the auction is regulated in
the Minister of Finance regulation number 05 / PMK.08 / 2012 concerning the
Issuance and Sale of State Sharia Securities in the Domestic Primary Market by
Auction Method as amended by Regulation of the Minister of Finance Number 20 /
PMK.08 / 2017, the contract used in SPNS sukuk trading uses the Ijarah
Sale and Lease Back agreement based on fatwas National Sharia
Council - Indonesian Ulema Council (DSN-MUI) number 72 / DSN-MUI / VI /
2008 (DSN-MUI, 2008). The
following are the terms and conditions of the SPNS (Djppr, 2019).
Table 9 Term and Condition of
Sharia State Treasury Bills (SPNS)
Term
and Condition |
SPN-S
08102020 (new
issuance) |
SPN-S
08012021 (new
issuance) |
Due
date |
8
October 2020 |
January
8, 2021 |
Rewards |
Discount |
Discount |
Underlying
Asset |
Projects
/ Activities in the 2020 State Budget and State Property |
Projects
/ Activities in the 2020 State Budget and State Property |
Auction
Date |
7
April 2020 |
7
April 2020 |
Settlement
Date |
April
9, 2020 |
April
9, 2020 |
Non-competitive
Purchase Allocation |
50%
of the amount won |
30%
of the amount won |
Indicative
Targets |
IDR
7,000,000,000,000.00 |
IDR
7,000,000,000,000.00 |
Bidders |
Bank:
(1) PT. Bank Mandiri (Persero), Tbk (2) PT. Bank Rakyat Indonesia
(Persero), Tbk (3) PT. Bank Negara Indonesia (Persero), Tbk (4)
PT. Bank Permata, Tbk (5) PT. Bank Panin, Tbk (6) PT. Bank
HSBC Indonesia (7) PT. Bank OCBC NISP, Tbk (8) Standard Chartered Bank
(9) PT. Bank CIMB Niaga, Tbk (10) PT. Bank Maybank Indonesia, Tbk
(11) Citibank NA (12) PT. Bank Negara Indonesia Syariah (13)
PT. Bank Central Asia, Tbk (14) Deutsche Bank AG (15) PT. Bank BNP
Paribas Indonesia (16) PT. Bank Syariah Mandiri (17) PT. Bank
BRISyariah, Tbk |
Bank:
(1) PT. Bank Mandiri (Persero), Tbk (2) PT. Bank Rakyat Indonesia
(Persero), Tbk (3) PT. Bank Negara Indonesia (Persero), Tbk (4)
PT. Bank Permata, Tbk (5) PT. Bank Panin, Tbk (6) PT. Bank
HSBC Indonesia (7) PT. Bank OCBC NISP, Tbk (8) Standard Chartered Bank
(9) PT. Bank CIMB Niaga, Tbk (10) PT. Bank Maybank Indonesia, Tbk
(11) Citibank NA (12) PT. Bank Negara Indonesia Syariah (13)
PT. Bank Central Asia, Tbk (14) Deutsche Bank AG (15) PT. Bank BNP
Paribas Indonesia (16) PT. Bank Syariah Mandiri (17) PT. Bank
BRISyariah, Tbk |
Securities
Companies: (1) PT. Danareksa Sekuritas (2) PT. Mandiri Sekuritas
(3) PT. Trimegah Sekuritas Indonesia, Tbk (4) PT. Bahana Securities |
Securities
Companies: (1) PT. Danareksa Sekuritas (2) PT. Mandiri Sekuritas
(3) PT. Trimegah Sekuritas Indonesia, Tbk (4) PT. Bahana Securities |
Source:
Directorate of Sharia Financing, Ministry of Finance
Project Based Sukuk (PBS)
Published
in 2011 with medium to long tenor with fixed yield aimed at institutional
investors through domestic primary market auction. The same is the case
with the State Sharia Treasury (SPSN), Project Based Sukuk
(PBS) where the auction is simultaneously carried out with SPSN where PBS uses
the Ijarah Asset to be Leased agreement based on the DSN-MUI fatwa number 76 /
DSN -MUI / VI / 2010 (DSN-MUI, 2010). Following
are the terms and conditions of the Project Based Sukuk (PBS)
which aims to finance the 2020 State Budget, the auction is conducted openly
which can submit bids at auction but purchases through auction participants who
have received approval from the Ministry of Finance of the Republic
of Indonesia (djppr, 2020).
Table 10 Term and Condition Project
Based Sukuk (PBS)
Term
and Condition |
PBS002 (reopening) |
PBS026 (reopening) |
PBS004 (reopening) |
PBS005 (reopening) |
Due
date |
January
15, 2022 |
15
October 2024 |
15
February 2037 |
April
15, 2043 |
Rewards |
5.45000% |
6.62500% |
6,10000% |
6.75000% |
Underlying
Asset |
Projects
/ Activities in the 2020 State Budget and State Property |
|||
Auction
Date |
7
April 2020 |
|||
Settlement
Date |
April
9, 2020 |
|||
Non-competitive
Purchase Allocation |
30%
of the amount won |
|||
Indicative
Targets |
IDR
7,000,000,000,000.00 |
|||
Bidders |
Bank: (1)
PT. Bank Mandiri (Persero), Tbk (2) PT. Bank Rakyat Indonesia
(Persero), Tbk (3) PT. Bank Negara Indonesia (Persero), Tbk (4)
PT. Bank Permata, Tbk (5) PT. Bank Panin, Tbk (6) PT. Bank
HSBC Indonesia (7) PT. Bank OCBC NISP, Tbk (8) Standard Chartered Bank
(9) PT. Bank CIMB Niaga, Tbk (10) PT. Bank Maybank Indonesia, Tbk
(11) Citibank NA (12) PT. Bank Negara Indonesia Syariah (13)
PT. Bank Central Asia, Tbk (14) Deutsche Bank AG (15) PT. Bank BNP
Paribas Indonesia (16) PT. Bank Syariah Mandiri (17) PT. Bank
BRISyariah, Tbk |
|||
Securities
Companies : (1) PT. Danareksa Sekuritas (2)
PT. Mandiri Sekuritas (3) PT. Trimegah Sekuritas Indonesia, Tbk (4)
PT. Bahana Securities |
Source:
Directorate of Sharia Financing, Ministry of Finance
Savings Sukuk (ST)
Issued
in 2016 as part of the retail rate, aimed at domestic investors with a minimum
purchase of 2 million, using a fixed yield system that is paid every month
(tenor 2 years). Savings sukuk with series ST-001 on 22 August - 2
September 2016 with a 2-year tenor with a yield of 6.9% per year that cannot be
traded on the secondary market ( non-tradable ), this savings
sukuk aims to finance the state budget (djppr) (Ministry of Finance, 2018). Savings
sukuk have almost the same objectives in broad outline for the types of State
Sharia Securities or SBSN, namely to help finance the state budget by building
infrastructure development, education, health and also helping the government
in limiting the arrival of foreign investors (Hastuti, 2018).
Green Sukuk (GT)
The
issuance of sukuk in all series issued by the government has the same
objectives, namely to help finance the state budget and government projects,
according to Suherman (Suherman, 2019) in
his research that green bonds are the development of green
sukuk in the country and show a positive increase until 2029, the
number of enthusiasts from domestic investors towards this type of sukuk
besides that demand from foreign investors is also very good for the state
sukuk market. The following is the development of green sukuk
for the year based on the green sukuk report in March 2020 where the Government
of Indonesia has issued green sukuk during the period February 2018 and 2019
with the number of the Indonesian Government having issued two global
sovereign green sukuk Twice in a row in 2018 amounting to US $
1, 25 billion and US $ 750 million with a total amount of US $ 2 billion, here
are the developments of green sukuk in Indonesia (Ministry of Finance, 2020).
1.
Each issue is divided
into 49% new project financing while 51% for existing project financing, the
results are allocated to several sectors which are a collaboration between the
Ministry of Transportation, the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources and
the Ministry of Work and Housing, namely;
a. For
renewable energy.
b. Climate
change resilience for areas that are highly vulnerable or at risk of disasters.
c. Energy
efficiency.
d. Waste
management and waste into energy.
e. Sustainable
transportation.
2.
Allocation by sector
Table
11
Allocation by Sector for Green Sukuk
Sector |
2018 |
2019 |
For
renewable energy |
102,519,477
(8%) |
41,262,073
(5%) |
Climate
change resilience for areas that are highly vulnerable or at risk of
disasters |
209,818,308
(17%) |
80,217,156
(11%) |
Energy
efficiency |
73,167,36
(6%) |
202,719,713
(27%) |
Waste
management and waste into energy |
92,598,526
(7%) |
69,492,775
(9%) |
Sustainable
transportation. |
772,805,236
(62%) |
360,480,724
(48%) |
3.
Allocation based on
activity
In
2018 adaptation was 17% and mitigation was 83%, while in 2019 adaptation was
11% and mitigation was 89%.
4.
Geographical spread of
the 2019 green sukuk project
Table
12
Distribution of 2019 green sukuk project locations
Sector |
Location |
For renewable
energy |
Papua, West
Papua, East Nusa Tenggara, North Sulawesi, Sulawesi, North Sulawesi,
Southeast Sulawesi, South Kalimantan, North Kalimantan ,
East Kalimantan , West Sumatra, Riau, Gorontalo, West Kalimantan, North Sumatra,
Central Java, West Java, Maluku, West Nusa Tenggara |
Climate change
resilience for areas that are highly vulnerable or at risk of disasters |
West Java,
Central Java, Yogyakarta, North Sumatra, West Sumatra, North Sulawesi,
Maluku, Bali |
Energy efficiency |
Jakarta, Central Java, East Java, Aceh, North
Sumatra, West Sumatra, Riau, South Sumatra, West Kalimantan, South
Kalimantan, West Kalimantan, North Kalimantan, North Sulawesi, South
Sulawesi, Southeast Sulawesi, Maluku, Bali, East Nusa Tenggara Timur , Papua,
West Papua, West Java |
Waste management
and waste into energy |
All Provinces
except East Kalimantan |
Sustainable
transportation. |
North Sumatra,
West Sumatra, North Sumatra, Jakarta, West Java, Central Java, East Java |
Conclusion
The state sharia securities or SBSN issued
by the Government of Indonesia have gone through a very long journey starting
from 2004. Domestic investors are more familiar with the term sukuk, the
purpose of issuing various series of sukuk is to help finance the APBN through
various government projects. SBSN or sukuk with various series
including Islamic Fixed Rate (IFR) sukuk, retail
sukuk, green sukuk, savings sukuk, Indonesian hajj fund sukuk
(SDHI), Project Based Sukuk (PBS), Sharia State Treasury
(SPNS). Sukuk financing is allocated mostly for government projects
throughout Indonesia, so it is clear that the dominance of its financing is
allocated for infrastructure activities such as building roads, bridges,
hospitals, educational facilities at various levels.
REFERENCES
Aminy, Muhammad Habibullah. (2018). Development Of
Sharia Bond (Sukuk) In Indonesia. Iqtishaduna. 9 (2), 135�147.
Ardi, Muhammad. (2018). The Effect of Sukuk on Indonesia�s Economic
Growth. Iqtishaduna. 9 (1), 36�46.
Bank Indonesia. (2018). Position Of State Securities (SBN). Retrieved
July 4, 2020, from bi.go.id. Retrieved from website:
https://www.bi.go.id/seki/tabel/TABEL4_4.pdf
Creswell, John W., & Clark, Vicki L. Plano. (2017). Designing and
conducting mixed methods research. Sage publications.
Directorate General of Financing and Risk Management. (2015). Issuance
of State Sharia Securities Series SDHI 2023 A through the Placement of Haii
Funds. Retrieved August 7, 2020, from the Ministry of Finance. Retrieved
from website:
https://www.djppr.kemenkeu.go.id/uploads/files/dmodata/in/9Berita/SBSN/2015/SP_SDHI
2023A (IND) .pdf
Directorate of Sharia Financing. (2018). State Sukuk and National
Development Financing. Retrieved August 7, 2020, from 7 th IndonesiaX
Educational Conference: �Islamic Economics and Finance: Present and Future.�
Retrieved from website:
https://seminar.indonesiax.co.id/files/07/suminto.pdf?raw=true
DJPPR. (2020). Planned Auction of State Sharia Securities or State
Sukuk on April 7, 2020. Retrieved August 7, 2020,.
Djppr. (2019). Sharia State Treasury Bills (SPNS). Retrieved from
kemenkeu.go.id. Retrieved from website:
https://www.djppr.kemenkeu.go.id/#/id/page/produk
DSN-MUI. (2019). DSNMUI No.80 / DSNMUI / III / 2011. Retrieved March
10, 2019, from DSN-MUI. Retrieved from website:
https://dsnmui.or.id/category/fatwa/page/5/
DSN-MUI. (2008). fatwa of the National Sharia Council - Indonesian
Ulema Council (DSN-MUI) number 72 / DSN-MUI / VI / 2008 .
DSN-MUI. (2010). DSN-MUI Fatwa number 76 / DSN-MUI / VI / 2010
concerning Project Based Sukuk (PBS). , dsnmui.or.id � (2010).
Fauziah, Syifa, & Nurwahidin, Nurwahidin. (2020). Infrastructure
Financing with Sukuk Negara in Indonesia: Procedure and Structure. MEA
Scientific Journal (Management, Economics, & Accounting), 4 (1),
30�42.
Finance., Ministry of. (n.d.). State Sharia Securities. Retrieved July
15, 2020. Retrieved from website:
https://www.djppr.kemenkeu.go.id/page/load/1656
Hariyanto, Eri. (2015). Reputation of Indonesia�s Global Sukuk.
Directorate General of Finance and Risk Management, Ministry of Finance of the
Republic of Indonesia .
Hariyanto, Eri. (2017). The Strategic Role of State Sukuk. Retrieved
July 16, 2020, from the Directorate of Sharia Financing, DJPPR, Ministry of
Finance website: Retrieved from
https://www.djppr.kemenkeu.go.id/page/load/1770
Hastuti, Erma Sri. (2018). Savings Sukuk: Sharia Investment Supports
Inclusive Economic Development. Journal of Jurisprudence, 7 (2),
114�122. Retrieved from
Hendri, Zul. (2018). Can Sukuk Become a Primadonna In Indonesia? Judging
From The Development of Sukuk In Several Countries. IQTISHADUNA: Jurnal
Ilmiah Ekonomi Kita, 7(2), 168�179.
Hidayat, Taufik. (2011). Smart Book of Sharia Investments (1st ed.).
Retrieved from ((1st ed.)). Retrieved from
https://books.google.co.id/books?hl=en&lr=&id=2nPqgz2eJRoC&oi=fnd&pg=PR3&dq=Investment+in
+ Islam & ots = 655FBa1Nag & sig = QV7DZe3QqEv = NAVxKmt4V &
investment
IDX Islamic. (n.d.). Sharia Products. Retrieved November 15, 2018,.
Retrieved from website: http://www.idx.co.id/idx-syariah/produk-syariah
Indriasari, Ika. (2018). Analysis of Selection of Sukuk as an Investment
Instrument. Stability: Journal of Management and Business, 1 (1).
Juaris, Juaris, Masbar, Raja, & Seftarita, Chenny. (2018). Analysis of
The Effect of Monetary Policy on Government Sharia Securities (SBSN) in
Indonesia. Sriwijaya International Journal of Dynamic Economics and Business,
2(2), 109�122.
Ministry of Finance. (2016). State Sharia Securities. Retrieved July
15, 2020, from Djppr.kemenkeu.go.id. Retrieved from website:
https://www.djppr.kemenkeu.go.id/page/load/1656
Ministry of Finance. (2018). It has been a decade of State Sukuk
Contribution to the Benefit of the Nation .
Ministry of Finance. (2020). Retail Sukuk Project #
InvestasiRakyatPenuhMan Benefits. Retrieved July 4, 2020,.
Ministry of Religion of the Republic of Indonesia. (2015). Al-Qur�an
and its Translation . Semarang: Semarang: PT.Kumudasmoro Grafindo.
Nopijantoro, Wurjanto. (2018). Surat Berharga Syariah Negara Project Based
Sukuk (SBSN PBS): sebuah Instrumen Alternatif Partisipasi Publik dalam
Pembiayaan Infrastruktur. Substansi, 1(2), 390�406.
President of the Republic of Indonesia. (2008). UU no. 19 of 2008
concerning SBSN .
Rahman, Maya Puspa Binti, Duasa, Jarita, Kassim, Salina, & Zainudin,
Wan Rahini Aznie. (2017). Sovereign Sukuk Pricing Analysis: Do Macroeconomic
Variables Matter? International Journal of Economics, Management and
Accounting, 25(3), 513�528.
Risk, Directorate General of Financing Management and. (2016). For the
First Time, the Government Issued Global Dual-Tranche Sukuk. Retrieved August
6, 2019, from the Ministry of Finance�s website: h. Retrieved from
ttps://www.kemenkeu.go.id/publikasi/berita/pertama-kalinya-pemerintah-terbiten-sukuk-global-dual-tranche/
Sianipar, Ibn SYifa Al Habib. (2019). Analysis of Hajj Fund Management
in Indonesian Hajj Sukuk Funds . North Sumatra State Islamic University.
Sillah, Bukhari M. S. (2018). Project-backed sukuk: Can it be a model for
resource mobilization, risk sharing and capital market development in
developing economies. Journal of Islamic Banking & Finance, 35(1),
68�83.
Smaoui, Houcem, & Khawaja, Mohsin. (2017). The determinants of Sukuk
market development. Emerging Markets Finance and Trade, 53(7),
1501�1518.
Suherman, Suherman. (2019). Identification of the Green Sukuk Market
Potential of the Republic of Indonesia. Human Falah: Journal of Islamic
Economics and Business, 1 (6).
Ulumuddin, S. Y. (2016). Analisis Perbandingan Kinerja Obligasi Syariah
Negara Dengan Obligasi Konvensional Negara Pada Periode 2008-2016 (Survey Pada
Sukuk Ritel Indonesia, Surat Berharga Syariah Negara, Surat Perbendaharaan
Negara, Obligasi Ritel Indonesia, dan Obligasi Negara Republik Indonesia).
Universitas Widyatama.
Utami, Datien Eriska, Trinugroho, Irwan, & Sergi, Bruno S. (2019). What
Determines Sukuk Issuance Type in Indonesia?�, Asia-Pacific Contemporary
Finance and Development (International Symposia in Economic Theory and
Econometrics, Volume 26). Emerald Publishing Limited.
Yaya, Rizal, & Sofiyana, Ekta. (2018). Pengaruh Sukuk Ritel Pemerintah
Terhadap Penghimpunan Dana Pihak Ketiga Bank Syariah. Media Riset Akuntansi,
Auditing & Informasi, 18(2), 153�168.