Syntax Literate: Jurnal Ilmiah Indonesia p–ISSN:
2541-0849 e-ISSN: 2548-1398
Vol. 9, No.
12, Desember 2024
RESEARCH AND APPLICATION
OF OPTIMIZATION TRANSFORMATION OF CIRCULATING WATER PUMP IMPELLER
Li Sheng1, Yin
Yanjie2, Muhammad Afuwan Laragau3
PT.
DSSP Power Kendari, Indonesia1,2,3
Email: li.sheng@dsspower.co.id1, yin.yanjie@dsspower.co.id2, afuwan.laragau@dsspower.co.id3
Abstract
The reasons why the circulating water pump can only operate at less than 30 % of the outlet quick-closing valve opening are analyzed . The turning ratio law is used to calculate and analyze the turning size of the impeller. A plan for turning and modifying the circulating water pump impeller is proposed, which enables the circulating water pump outlet quick-closing valve to be fully opened and the motor current to operate within the allowable range. The economic efficiency of the circulating water pump impeller after modification is calculated, achieving the purpose of energy saving and consumption reduction. This study aims to analyze the causes of these inefficiencies and propose a solution by modifying the impeller through turning and recalibration. The turning ratio law was applied to calculate the appropriate size of the impeller, ensuring full valve opening while maintaining the motor current within permissible limits. Post-modification results demonstrated enhanced economic efficiency, reduced power consumption, and improved pump performance, achieving energy savings and consumption reduction. The study concludes that impeller turning is a practical and effective method for optimizing circulating water pump operations in thermal power plants.
Keywords: circulating water pump; cause of overcurrent ; impeller turning calculation; impeller transformation; energy saving; consumption reduction
Introduction
The circulating water pump is an
important auxiliary machine of the thermal power unit, and its energy
consumption accounts for 1% to 1.5% of the power consumption rate of the
thermal power unit. In the actual operation process
Unit Overview
The circulating water system of Kendari Power
Plant adopts an expanded unit system. Each unit is equipped with two
circulating water pumps with 50% capacity and a circulating water supply main
pipe. The circulating water supply main pipes of the two units are connected
after the electric butterfly valve at the outlet of the circulating water pump
Table 1. Main
technical specifications of steam turbine
|
project name |
Steam Turbine Design Technical Specifications |
|
Unit Type |
Model: N 56 —— 8.83 /535 |
|
Rated power/MW |
56 MW |
|
Main steam pressure/MPa |
8.83 ±0.5MPa |
|
Main steam temperature/℃ |
535 ℃ |
|
Main steam flow t/h |
2 08.5 t/h |
|
Exhaust pressure MPa |
0.00 84 M Pa |
Table 2. Main
technical specifications of circulating water pump
|
project name |
Design technical specifications for single circulating water pump |
|
Circulating water pump operation mode |
Two machines and three pumps in parallel Single machine and two pumps in parallel |
|
Flow rate/ M³/h |
7070 M³/h |
|
Lift/M |
37M |
|
Shaft power/KW |
1000KW |
|
Pump efficiency/ % |
87% |
|
Impeller average diameter/mm |
759,5 mm |
Table 3. Main
technical specifications of circulating water pump motor
|
project name |
Fixed speed motor |
|
Rated voltage/KV |
6000KV |
|
Rated power/KW |
1000KW |
|
Current/A |
128.4A |
|
Power Factor |
0.82 |
|
Speed/r |
743r |
1) Analysis of the causes of overcurrent
in circulating water pump motor
The design head
of the circulating water pump is 37 meters, see Figure 1, and the design
circulating water flow rate of single unit operation is 13860m³/h, see Figure 1
%207591-7601.fld/image002.jpg)
%207591-7601.fld/image004.jpg)
Figure 1. Design Head
%207591-7601.fld/image006.jpg)
Figure 2. Circulating water pump
flow
According to the current operating
status of the unit, the operating parameters of the dual-machine single pump
and single-machine dual pump were actually tested on site. When the opening of
the circulating water pump outlet hydraulic control butterfly valve was at 30%,
the outlet main pipe pressure was 0.2Mpa and the flow rate was about 20000T,
which fully met the condenser vacuum demand. This reflects that the design
parameters of the circulating water system have a large deviation from the
actual operating parameters. The design parameters of the circulating water
pump are greater than the actual requirements of the system, resulting in the
circulating water pump having to operate with limited parameters, otherwise the
motor will overcurrent.
2) Impeller turning amount
calculation and economic analysis
The cutting amount of the impeller
outer diameter can be calculated by using the universal cutting law of the
water pump impeller.
The cutting law is
calculated as follows:
![]()
Where: Q1—flow rate
before turning the outer diameter, m 3 / s;
H1—lift before
turning the outer diameter, m;
P1—shaft power
before turning the outer diameter, kW;
D1—impeller outer
diameter before turning, mm;
Q2—flow rate after
turning the outer diameter, m 3 / s;
H2—lift after
turning the outer diameter, m;
P2—Shaft power
after turning the outer diameter, kW
D2—Outer diameter
of the impeller after turning, mm.
The formula calculates that the
outer diameter of the circulating water pump impeller is 25mm. According to the
above calculation results, the relevant water pump manufacturer is commissioned
to turn the outer diameter of the circulating water pump impeller by 25mm.
After that, the current of the D circulating pump motor drops to 121A, the
outlet hydraulic control butterfly valve can be fully opened, and a single
machine and a single pump can meet the condenser vacuum above -92,5 kPa, saving
one circulating pump operation.
The solution of turning the outer
diameter of the impeller reduces the current of the circulating water pump to
within the design range, ensuring the safe and stable operation of the
circulating water pump, and at the same time increasing the economic benefits
of the unit to a certain extent. Based on the calculation that a single
circulating water pump runs 365 days a year, the unit can save plant
electricity consumption annually: P = 365×24×UI (720) = 8.76 million kW·h. Based on the current on-grid electricity price of
0.77 yuan/kW·h, the cost can be saved by 6.75 million
yuan per year.
Research Methods
1. Affinity Laws Calculation
Affinity Laws for predicting performance changes due to impeller trimming.
Affinity Laws:
![]()
Method: Predictions made using these law before impeller trimming.
To evaluate the effect of impeller trimming on pump performance, such as efficiency, head, flow rate, and power consumption.
Method:
Conduct baseline testing of the pump with the original impeller.
Incrementally reduce the impeller diameter by cutting around 5%, 10% (based on prediction using affinity laws)
Perform tests after trim, measuring key performance parameter.
Tools: Flow meters, pressure gauges.
Result and Discussion
Data pump
production test and analysis report can be seen in the Figure below.
%207591-7601.fld/image010.jpg)
Figure 3. Pump performance test data from
manufacturing
Initial
data collection was carried out to determine the initial pump performance
parameters, the first test was carried out on the CWP D pump. It can be seen in
the figure below, the flow rate readings fluctuate
greatly due to inaccurate measuring instruments.
%207591-7601.fld/image012.jpg)
Figure 4.
Parameter CWP D Before Improvement
First Test
The first
test was carried out on the CWP D pump. The test was carried out by cutting the
impeller to a depth of 25mm (around 6.6%) for each blade with a rectangular
model.
Approach using
affinity laws:
D1 (Average
Diameter) : 759,5 mm
Q2/Q1 = D2/D1
Q2/9225 = 709,5/759,5
Q2 = 8617 m³/h
Impeller trimming
was conducted using CNC machine.
%207591-7601.fld/image014.jpg)
Figure 5. Impeller Trimming First Test on CWP D
The results
of the tests carried out can be seen in the figure below.
%207591-7601.fld/image016.jpg)
Figure 6. Parameter
After Improvement CWP D
It can be
seen from the test results after cutting the impeller
1. Effect
of impeller trimming is a reduction
in the flow rate.
There is reduction of flow 571 m³/h in fully opening of outlet valve.
2. The outlet pressure of pump in fully opening of outlet
valve is still same 0,19 MPa for both before and after improvement.
3. Motor current is decrease from 134,1A to 125,4 A in
fully opening of outlet valve. After several months running, motor current is
decrease to Around 121-122 A
4. The occurrence of noise on the impeller side is due to cavitation, this
is related to the square-shaped impeller cutting model. After several months of
operations, the noise disappeared.
5. During the test, single pump was tested for supply cooling water to condensor. The vacuum condenser were
still good in the range of - 92,5 kPa and steam exhaust temperature of turbine
was 41-42°C.
Conclusion of improvement CWP D successful, in
fully open position of valve the motor current is below the rating current at
the name plate 128,4 A. The cooling effect on the condenser is good even with a
single pump. Increase the unit efficiency with reduce auxiliary consumption.
Second Test
The
second test was carried out on CWP B, the cutting model was changed to a
circular arc to avoid cavitation problems, The total area of the impeller cut
is also slightly increased with the aim of reducing motor current, related to
motor reliability. Impeller cutting depth is 30 mm with circular arc model
(around 7,1 %).
%207591-7601.fld/image018.jpg)
Figure 7. Impeller Trimming Second Test on CWP B
Test result were obtained in fully opening of outlet valve
Outlet pump pressure : 0,16 MPa
Motor current :
120 A
Vacuum Condensor : -91,6 kPa
Exhaust Temperature : 42°C
Condensor circulating water inlet pressure
: 0,06-0,07 MPa.
The flow rate
parameter is not a reference because it is very fluctuating.
Noise due to
cavitation no longer occurs.
The conclusion
at improvement at CWP B, all parameters are good. Single pump mode can create a
good cooling effect on the condenser system. The model of trimming impeller at
picture 2 is successfull and has been applied to CWP
C and CWP A
Conclusion
It was analyzed that the cause of
overcurrent in the circulating water pump motor was design reasons. The
designed circulating pump head was 37 meters, and the actual required head was
20 meters, which exceeded the actual head by 17 meters. The operation of the
outlet door was restricted to prevent the motor from overloading. Aiming at the
cause of overcurrent in circulating water pump, a transformation plan of
turning impeller was proposed. After turning the outer diameter of circulating
water pump impeller by 25mm, the current of circulating water pump was within
the design range and the outlet valve of circulating water pump could be fully
opened for operation. After the impeller turning transformation of the
circulating water pump, the operation mode of single machine two pumps and
double machines three pumps was changed to single machine single pump operation
mode, which saved one circulating water pump operation throughout the year.
Calculated based on 365 days of operation per year, the factory electricity
consumption can be saved by 8.76 million kW·h and the
cost can be saved by 6.75 million yuan, which has considerable economic
benefits.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Adi, D. M. P., & Garniwa, I. (2022). Analysis of The Impact of
Sedimentation Dredging on Headloss Repair &
Operating Patterns of CWP (Circulating Water Pump) PLTU Lontar. Energi
& Kelistrikan, 14(1).
https://doi.org/10.33322/energi.v14i1.1649
Arun Shankar, V. K., Umashankar, S., Paramasivam, S.,
& Hanigovszki, N. (2016). A comprehensive review
on energy efficiency enhancement initiatives in centrifugal pumping system. In
Applied Energy (Vol. 181).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apenergy.2016.08.070
Augustyn, T. (2012). Energy
efficiency and savings in pumping systems - The holistic approach. 2012
Southern African Energy Efficiency Convention, SAEEC 2012.
https://doi.org/10.1109/SAEEC.2012.6408587
Bai, Y., Kong, F., Xia, B., Zhao,
F., & Liu, Y. (2017). Effects of Impeller Diameter on High-Speed Rescue
Pump. Mathematical Problems in Engineering, 2017.
https://doi.org/10.1155/2017/1387210
Khamudkhanov, M. M., Abdullabekov,
I. A., Khamudkhanova, N. B., Dusmatov,
R. K., & Fayzullayev, B. K. H. (2020). Controls
of the modes of operation of the pumping station with application of
frequency-controlled electric drive. IOP Conference Series: Materials
Science and Engineering, 862(6).
https://doi.org/10.1088/1757-899X/862/6/062048
Khoeini, D., & Tavakoli,
M. R. (2018). Flow characteristics of a centrifugal pump with different
impeller trimming methods. FME Transactions, 46(4).
https://doi.org/10.5937/fmet1804463K
Li, W.-G. (2011). Impeller Trimming
of an Industrial Centrifugal Viscous Oil Pump. In Int J Advanced Design and
Manufacturing Technology (Vol. 5, Issue 1).
Liu, F., Song, C., Pan, W., Wang,
G., Zhang, H., & Lei, Y. (2024). Thermal fatigue analysis of district
heating pipeline under variable frequency regulation of circulating water
pump. Applied Thermal Engineering, 242.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.applthermaleng.2024.122535
Ma, Y. Y., Yan, S., Yang, Z. G.,
Qi, G. S., & He, X. Y. (2015). Failure analysis on circulating water pump
of duplex stainless steel in 1000MW ultra-supercritical thermal power unit. Engineering
Failure Analysis, 47(PA).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.engfailanal.2014.09.014
Matlakala, M. E., Kallon, D. V. V., Mogapi,
K. E., Mabelane, I. M., & Makgopa,
D. M. (2019). Influence of Impeller Diameter on the Performance of Centrifugal
pumps. IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering, 655(1).
https://doi.org/10.1088/1757-899X/655/1/012009
Muhammad, Z. (2020). Penentuan Head dan Daya Pompa Sirkulasi
Air (Circulating Water Pump/CWP) Dalam Menunjang Eefektipitas Kerja Kondendor. Universitas
Bandar Lampung.
Shu, K., Yu, X., Zhang, B., Xie,
F., Tao, X., Zhu, M., & Mao, H. (2018). The effect of impeller cut on the
performance of middle specific speed centrifugal pump. IOP Conference
Series: Materials Science and Engineering, 394(3).
https://doi.org/10.1088/1757-899X/394/3/032042
Wang, H., & Wang, H. (2019).
Enhance hydraulic balance of a district cooling system with multiple jet pump.
Energy Procedia, 158.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.egypro.2019.01.412
Wang, K., Zhang, Z., Jiang, L.,
Liu, H., & Li, Y. (2017). Effects of impeller trim on performance of
two-stage self-priming centrifugal pump. Advances in Mechanical Engineering,
9(2). https://doi.org/10.1177/1687814017692493
Yang, F., Zhao, H. R., & Liu,
C. (2016). Improvement of the efficiency of the axial-flow pump at part loads
due to installing outlet guide vanes mechanism. Mathematical Problems in
Engineering, 2016. https://doi.org/10.1155/2016/6375314
Zhou, P., Tang, J., Mou, J., &
Zhu, B. (2016). Effect of impeller trimming on performance. World Pumps,
2016(9). https://doi.org/10.1016/S0262-1762(16)30238-3
Zwierzchowski, R., Niemyjski, O.,
& Wołowicz, M. (2022). Energy Savings Analysis
for Operation of Steam Cushion System for Sensible Thermal Energy Storages. Energies,
15(1). https://doi.org/10.3390/en15010286
|
Copyright holder: Li
Sheng, Yin Yanjie, Muhammad Afuwan
Laragau (2024) |
|
First publication right: Syntax Literate: Jurnal Ilmiah Indonesia |
|
This article is licensed under: |