Syntax Literate: Jurnal Ilmiah Indonesia p–ISSN: 2541-0849 e-ISSN: 2548-1398
Vol. 9, No. 1, Januari 2024
ANALYSIS OF THE APPLICATION OF RISK
MANAGEMENT IN PT. PERTAMINA TBBM TANJUNG PRIOK TO IMPROVE NON-FINANCIAL FIRM
(CASE STUDY: TANK CONSTRUCTION X - TANJUNG PRIOK)
M. Fanshurullah Asa*, Yessy
Rama Natalia Pakpahan, Okfi
Risa Sabila
Universitas Pertamina, Indonesia
Email: [email protected]*, [email protected],
Abstract
PT Pertamina TBBM Tanjung Priok
- Plumpang is one of the
downstream oil facilities that plays an important
role in the distribution and distribution of fuel for the
community. Because, about 20% of the
daily fuel needs in Indonesia are supplied from TBBM Tanjung Priok - Plumpang owned by PT Pertamina (Persero). In the
course of time, many incidents
(fire, etc.) within the scope of
TBBM Plumpang. Therefore, this research aims to examine the application of Risk Management
in the company PT Pertamina
TBBM Tanjung Priok - Plumpang.
This research uses a qualitative approach conducted through a process of interviews and
direct observation. The purpose of applying
Risk Management to this company
is to identify
what risks are involved in Risk Management within the scope of
PT Pertamina TBBM Tanjung Priok-Plumpang by measuring the
risk of probability
and impact, and evaluating each existing risk,
according to the case study of Tank X construction within the Tanjung Priok TBBM area. This research is expected
to assist management in taking actions and responses
to reduce the negative impacts
of the possibilities
that will occur in the future
and provide an assessment of
the various risks that exist.
The results of this study will contain risk classes
ranging from high risk, medium risk, and low
risk.
Keywords: Risk Management, Non – Financial
Performance, Risk, Impact
Introduction
The fire case at PT Pertamina
Plumpang Depot was shocking and saddening for the
people of Indonesia. When viewed from the outside, security issues and safety
SOPs at PT Pertamina Plumpang
itself are very strict. However, with the reason for the cause of the fire
which was analyzed from several sources that with the
occurrence of technical disturbances that resulted in excessive pressure so that
the fire occurred (Wirandaru, 2023). However, from other sources, the cause of the fire
at the Plumpang depot came from the fuel inlet pipe,
which is located close to the residential parapet. Pertamina's
depot, which is one of the most important fuel terminals in Indonesia and is
world-class, has also experienced a fire in 2009, which resulted in losses of
around 17 billion. After the incident, Vice President Jusuf Kalla
asked PT Pertamina (Persero) to maintain security and
safety standards at the oil refinery (Yakub & Phuspa,
2019).
The experience of the above events leads to the conclusion that even
though reports and checks are routinely issued, it does not mean that a company
is free from risks. In today's global era, attention to risk assessment is
fundamental. This is because in the global area, businesses are faced with an
environment of very high uncertainty and complexity (Aditya & Naomi,
2017). Moreover, as we know PT Pertamina Persero
is a company engaged in the oil and gas sector, so it must pay attention to
occupational health and safety (Health & Safety) which is a significant
problem and an important factor in determining excellence for competitiveness
and must require serious attention and management of efforts in the field of
occupational health and safety.
PT Pertamina
(Persero) is one of the leading national oil companies in Indonesia that plays
an important role in the distribution and procurement of oil and gas resources
in Indonesia. In this effort, of course, facilities are needed to store and
distribute these products so that people can utilize energy in meeting their
needs. The Fuel Oil Depot (BBM) in Priuk, North
Jakarta is one of the terminals owned by PT Pertamina
Patra Niaga as one of the entities of PT Pertamina (Persero) which holds responsibility for storing
and distributing production. The place
commonly used to store petroleum products is a tank. Tanks in the oil and gas
industry are structures that are used as storage for crude oil, LNG, and their
derivative products including fuel oil (BBM). In general, the oil storage tank
or liquid material is in the form of a cylinder which has a large enough
diameter. The activities of PT Pertamina Persero involve all aspects of the field, from
upstream to downstream. In accordance with Pertamina's
aspirations to become a Global Energy Champion with a market value of US $ 100
billion, of course, it must increase PT Pertamina's
consistency in the implementation of ESG (Environmental, Social &
Governance) aspects, especially those related to social aspects where
occupational health and safety are the main concerns, namely by providing
appropriate responses to risks that may occur. Of course, this is done with the
aim of minimizing the risk costs that will be incurred and increasing company
profits, increasing employee productivity and loyalty and for the sake of
maintaining the company's image in the eyes (international world). The research
aims to examine the application of Risk Management in the company PT Pertamina TBBM Tanjung Priok - Plumpang.
Research Methods
This research uses a qualitative method
with a descriptive approach (Creswell &
Creswell, 2017). In this study using qualitative methods where the
results of the analysis are in the form of analysis of each existing risk. This
research uses the following data collection methods:
Observation Technique
In this observation technique,
information is recorded when making observations in the field, precisely on the
X tank Upgrading project. This observation is carried out for later
interviews/discussions together with the contractor or owner. Observations in
the field also sometimes coincide with interview techniques where if at the
time of observation there are things that are not understood, then questions and
answers are asked with the contractor or owner. This observation is also
carried out if there is data that cannot be obtained through interviews.
Observation is also carried out to better understand technical matters related
to the project so that it makes it easier to analyze.
Documents
In this study,
document techniques were used where in this study documents were obtained in
the form of Project TOR, technical drawings, material approval letters obtained
from the contractor. These data are needed for the analysis needs in this study
which can be accounted for because they have gone through the approval process.
Interview
In this research, interview techniques were also
carried out where discussions were held with the executor in this case the
contractor and owner. This interview was conducted based on the results of
observations and project documents or other documents mentioned in the previous
section. Information from the interview results is used as an addition to the
analysis carried out.
Figure 1. Flowchart
Results
and Discussion
The risk analysis process involves
observing the job site to obtain an initial risk identification, and then analyzing it with a probability and impact matrix. This
risk identification is an iterative process where risks sometimes arise during
project implementation or throughout the project life cycle. Based on PMBOK
edition 6, this risk analysis is both qualitative and quantitative (Stackpole, 2013). Qualitatively, a risk prioritization analysis
process is carried out to be followed up with an assessment that can show the
likelihood of risk occurrence and its impact (Tavan & Hosseini,
2016). While quantitative is a numerical analysis which is a combination of
risk identification. The table below shows the results of the risk management
analysis on the oil tank lifting process that has been adjusted to the
assessment provisions in table 1.
Table
1. Hazard Table
NO |
Type Of Event |
Potential Hazards |
Consequences |
Consequences |
Intial Risk |
Safeguards (Existing and Recommended
Control Measures) |
Consequences |
Residual Risk |
||||||||||
People |
Asset |
Environment |
Reputation |
S |
L |
R |
People |
Asset |
Environment |
Reputation |
S |
L |
R |
|||||
1 |
Crawler crane installation |
Soil cannot bear
the weight of the crawler crane |
Crane has
decreased so that when lifting the tank it is unstable until it rolls over |
Multiple fatalities |
Extensive damage |
Local effect |
International impact |
4 |
3 |
High |
Testing the
compressive strength of the soil to determine the strength of the soil in
holding the load on it |
Minor injury |
Local damage |
Local effect |
Major impact |
3 |
3 |
Low |
tilt crawler
crane |
Load fell and
caused damage to equipment and tank |
Multiple fatalities |
Extensive damage |
Local effect |
International impact |
4 |
3 |
High |
The use of
cranes must be in accordance with the capacity requirements that have been
multiplied by the safety factor so that it is safer to hold the tank. |
Minor injury |
Local damage |
Local effect |
Major impact |
3 |
2 |
Low |
||
Crane
installation must be in accordance with the worker's briefing and signage. |
||||||||||||||||||
Use PPE to
reduce the risk of injury to workers |
||||||||||||||||||
Conduct a
re-briefing on OHS to reduce the risk of the same accident recurring. |
||||||||||||||||||
Physical injury
and loss of life if the tank falls or rolls over |
Multiple fatalities |
Major damage |
Local effect |
International impact |
5 |
3 |
High |
Complete use of
PPE in accordance with the standards where the project is carried out so as
to reduce the risk of fatal injuries. |
Minor injury |
Local damage |
Local effect |
Major impact |
3 |
2 |
Low |
|||
Loss in terms of
budget and loss in terms of time |
Major injury |
Extensive damage |
Local effect |
International impact |
5 |
3 |
High |
Work with good
concentration and focus so that there is less risk of human error when
operating the crane. |
Minor injury |
Local damage |
Local effect |
Major impact |
3 |
2 |
Low |
|||
Re-briefing on
OHS to prevent the same accident from occurring. |
||||||||||||||||||
|
Full PPE is used
to reduce the risk of fatal injury. |
|||||||||||||||||
Mast fall |
Physical injury
and loss of life if the tank falls or rolls over |
Fatality |
Major damage |
Local effect |
National impact |
4 |
3 |
Medium |
Work with good
concentration and focus so that there is less risk of human error when
operating the crane. |
Minor injury |
Minor damage |
Minor effect |
Limited impact |
2 |
2 |
Low |
||
Re-briefing on
OHS to prevent the same accident from occurring. |
||||||||||||||||||
Briefing on OHS
is conducted again to reduce the occurrence of the same incident |
||||||||||||||||||
Loss in terms of
budget and loss in terms of time |
No/slight injury |
Major damage |
Minor effect |
National impact |
3 |
3 |
Medium |
Use full PPE to
reduce the risk of injury. |
No/slight injury |
Minor damage |
Minor effect |
Limited impact |
2 |
2 |
Low |
|||
Work with good
concentration and focus so that there is less risk of human error when
operating the crane. |
||||||||||||||||||
The tank becomes
unbalanced and may cause the tank to topple over |
Multiple fatalities |
Extensive damage |
Major effect |
National impact |
5 |
3 |
High |
Crane operators
must be certified so that operations can be carried out properly. |
Minor injury |
Minor damage |
Local effect |
Limited impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
|||
Use full PPE to
avoid injury. |
||||||||||||||||||
Worker slips
during crane installation |
Workers suffer
fatal injuries and death |
Minor injury |
No/Slight damage |
Minor effect |
Minor impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
Full PPE is used
to reduce the risk of fatal injury. |
No/slight injury |
No/Slight damage |
Minor effect |
Limited impact |
2 |
2 |
Low |
||
Work with good
concentration and focus so that there is less risk of human error when
operating the crane. |
||||||||||||||||||
Work was
temporarily suspended due to an accident |
Minor injury |
No/Slight damage |
Minor effect |
Minor impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
Conduct a
re-briefing on OHS to reduce the risk of the same accident recurring. |
No/slight injury |
No/Slight damage |
Minor effect |
Limited impact |
2 |
2 |
Low |
|||
Jib broke due
to overload |
Workers suffer
fatal injuries and death |
Fatality |
Major damage |
Local effect |
National impact |
4 |
3 |
Medium |
Full PPE is used
to reduce the risk of fatal injury. |
Minor injury |
Minor damage |
Minor effect |
Limited impact |
2 |
2 |
Low |
||
Workers are
certified so they can operate the crane properly. |
||||||||||||||||||
Operators follow
directions and job signs |
||||||||||||||||||
Work with good
concentration and focus so that there is less risk of human error when
operating the crane. |
||||||||||||||||||
Loss in terms of
budget and loss in terms of time because the project is temporarily suspended |
No/slight injury |
Major damage |
Minor effect |
National impact |
3 |
3 |
Medium |
Re-direction of
K3 is carried out as an effort to avoid the re-occurrence of the same
accident. |
No/slight injury |
Minor damage |
Minor effect |
Limited impact |
2 |
2 |
Low |
|||
Damage to tools |
No/slight injury |
Major damage |
Minor effect |
National impact |
3 |
3 |
Medium |
Conduct a
re-briefing on OHS to reduce the risk of the same accident recurring. |
No/slight injury |
Minor damage |
Minor effect |
Limited impact |
2 |
2 |
Low |
|||
|
|
An earthquake
occurred during crane operation |
damage to tanks
near tank 22 |
Minor injury |
Local damage |
Minor effect |
Major impact |
3 |
3 |
Medium |
Operators who
operate cranes must be certified to avoid a high risk of accidents. |
Minor injury |
Minor damage |
Minor effect |
Limited impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
Analyze
whether the structure is strong against earthquakes or to maintain the
balance of the tank in the event of an earthquake. |
||||||||||||||||||
Workers suffer
fatal injuries and death |
Fatality |
Major damage |
Local effect |
National impact |
4 |
3 |
Medium |
Full PPE is used
to reduce the risk of fatal injuries. |
Minor injury |
Minor damage |
Minor effect |
Limited impact |
2 |
2 |
Low |
|||
Stay focused
while working to avoid fatal injuries if the tank topples over during an
earthquake |
||||||||||||||||||
Evacuate or give
first aid to accident victims. |
||||||||||||||||||
Damage to other
facilities near the tank 22 |
Fatality |
Major damage |
Major effect |
National impact |
3 |
3 |
Medium |
Analyze
whether the structure is strong against earthquakes or to maintain the
balance of the tank in the event of an earthquake. |
Major injury |
Local damage |
Minor effect |
Major impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
|||
Stopping
activities at the entire Tanjung Priok TBBM Installation due to accidental falling loads
to avoid other risks that cause huge losses in terms of profit and also in
terms of production or distribution. |
Fatality |
Major damage |
Major effect |
National impact |
3 |
4 |
High |
The analysis is
carried out first to get the balance of the tank in the event of an
earthquake so that there is no overturning of the tank due to an earthquake
or overturning of the crane. |
Major injury |
Local damage |
Minor effect |
Major impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
|||
Crane toppled
over and the load also toppled over |
||||||||||||||||||
Workers suffered
fatal injuries and even death |
Fatality |
Major damage |
Local effect |
National impact |
4 |
3 |
Medium |
Full PPE is used
to reduce the risk of fatal injuries. |
Minor injury |
Minor damage |
Minor effect |
Limited impact |
2 |
2 |
Low |
|||
Stay focused
while working to avoid fatal injuries if the tank topples over during an
earthquake |
||||||||||||||||||
Perform
evacuation or first aid on accident victims |
||||||||||||||||||
During sleewing, the crane hits the worker or another tank. |
damage to other
facilities at TBBM |
Fatality |
Major damage |
Major effect |
National impact |
3 |
3 |
Medium |
Operators who
operate cranes must be certified to avoid accidents. |
Major injury |
Local damage |
Minor effect |
Major impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
||
Must stay
focused while doing work so as to avoid accidents. |
||||||||||||||||||
Workers are
injured to the point of permanent disability or death. |
Fatality |
Major damage |
Major effect |
Major impact |
3 |
3 |
Medium |
Full PPE is used
to reduce the risk of fatal injuries. |
Major injury |
Local damage |
Minor effect |
Major impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
|||
Stay focused
while working to avoid fatal injuries if the tank topples over during an
earthquake |
||||||||||||||||||
Perform
evacuation or first aid on accident victims |
||||||||||||||||||
Patahan Jib
mengenai pekerja |
Fatality |
Local damage |
Minor effect |
Major impact |
4 |
3 |
Medium |
Use PPE to
reduce the risk of injury to workers |
Minor injury |
Minor damage |
Minor effect |
Limited impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
|||
Stay
concentrated while working to avoid being thrown by a broken Jib |
||||||||||||||||||
Crane suffers
engine failure |
Work was
temporarily halted resulting in losses in terms of time and cost |
No/slight injury |
Local damage |
No/Slight effect |
Major impact |
3 |
3 |
Medium |
Regular
maintenance is carried out to ensure that the crane is in optimum or good
condition when operating. |
No/slight injury |
Minor damage |
No/Slight effect |
Limited impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
||
Crane overturned
due to overload |
The load rolled
along with the crane, which could hit other facilities at the TBBM and incur
cost losses. |
Fatality |
Major damage |
Major effect |
National impact |
3 |
3 |
Medium |
Well analyzed for crane capacity calculation to avoid crane
overload. |
Major injury |
Local damage |
Minor effect |
Major impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
||
When analyzing the crane capacity, it has been multiplied by
the safety factor. |
||||||||||||||||||
Workers are
injured to the point of permanent disability or death. |
Fatality |
Major damage |
Major effect |
Major impact |
3 |
3 |
Medium |
Workers must
remain focused while doing their work because if an accident occurs, workers
can avoid it more quickly. Workers are also required to use complete PPE in
accordance with applicable regulations. In the event of a victim, immediately
provide help as early as possible. |
Major injury |
Local damage |
Minor effect |
Major impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
|||
There was a
collision between cranes |
Damage to
equipment and other facilities at TBBM |
Fatality |
Major damage |
Major effect |
Major impact |
3 |
3 |
Medium |
Operators who
operate cranes must be certified to avoid errors in operation. At the time of
operation must follow the signs of work at the project site. Continue to use
PPE in accordance with applicable standards. provide immediate first aid if
there are accident victims. |
Major injury |
Local damage |
Minor effect |
Major impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
||
Time and cost
losses due to crane collision accidents |
No/slight injury |
Local damage |
No/Slight effect |
Major impact |
3 |
3 |
Medium |
Operators who
operate cranes must be certified to avoid errors in operation. At the time of
operation must follow the signs of work at the project site. |
No/slight injury |
Minor damage |
No/Slight effect |
Limited impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
|||
Injury to crane
operator or injury to workers |
Fatality |
Major damage |
Major effect |
Major impact |
3 |
3 |
Medium |
Use PPE in
accordance with applicable standards and stay focused while working.
Immediately perform first aid in the event of an accident victim |
Major injury |
Local damage |
Minor effect |
Major impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
|||
Crane on fire |
Equipment
damaged by fire |
Minor injury |
Major damage |
Minor effect |
National impact |
3 |
3 |
Medium |
Cranes must be
maintained according to the schedule and not skip any part of the check
during maintenance. Crane operations must be carried out by professional and
certified operators. |
No/slight injury |
Minor damage |
Minor effect |
Limited impact |
2 |
2 |
Low |
||
Workers are
injured to death |
Fatality |
Major damage |
Major effect |
Major impact |
3 |
3 |
Medium |
Workers or
operators must comply with regulations regarding K3 at the project site and
continue to use PPE in accordance with applicable standards, if there are
victims then immediately provide assistance. |
Major injury |
Local damage |
Minor effect |
Major impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
|||
There are
disadvantages in terms of cost and in terms of time |
No/slight injury |
Local damage |
No/Slight effect |
Major impact |
3 |
3 |
Medium |
Workers or
operators must comply with regulations regarding K3 at the project site and
continue to use PPE in accordance with applicable standards, if there are
victims then immediately provide assistance. |
No/slight injury |
Minor damage |
No/Slight effect |
Limited impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
|||
Unsafe crane
height |
Crane terguling |
Fatality |
Major damage |
Major effect |
Major impact |
3 |
3 |
Medium |
Crane operation
must be in accordance with the standard or initial design that has been
planned and has been calculated and analyzed to
avoid accidents. Operators who operate the crane must be professional and
certified so that they can operate the crane properly. |
Major injury |
Local damage |
Minor effect |
Major impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
||
Crane has broken |
Fatality |
Major damage |
Major effect |
Major impact |
3 |
3 |
Medium |
Crane operation
must be in accordance with the standard or initial design that has been
planned and has been calculated and analyzed to
avoid accidents. Operators who operate the crane must be professional and
certified so that they can operate the crane properly. |
Major injury |
Local damage |
Minor effect |
Major impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
|||
Dropped or
rolled loads |
Multiple fatalities |
Extensive damage |
Major effect |
National impact |
5 |
3 |
High |
Crane operation
must be in accordance with the standard or initial design that has been
planned and has been calculated and analyzed to
avoid accidents. |
Minor injury |
Minor damage |
Local effect |
Limited impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
|||
Injury to
workers or death |
Fatality |
Major damage |
Major effect |
Major impact |
3 |
3 |
Medium |
Continue to use
complete PPE when working and comply with other OHS requirements when at the
project site. In the event of an accident victim immediately perform first
aid. |
Major injury |
Local damage |
Minor effect |
Major impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
|||
Workers breathe
in a lot of dust when cleaning crawler cranes |
Workers
experience oxygen deprivation and workers experience shortness of breath and
respiratory infections. |
Fatality |
Major damage |
Major effect |
Major impact |
3 |
3 |
Medium |
Workers use dust
masks when working in locations that produce a lot of dust. Workers use
complete PPE and comply with other OHS at the project site. Immediately
provide assistance if there are victims |
Major injury |
Local damage |
Minor effect |
Major impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
||
Workers
temporarily or permanently disabled due to respiratory infection |
Major injury |
Major damage |
Major effect |
Major impact |
3 |
3 |
Medium |
Workers use dust
masks when working in locations that produce a lot of dust. Workers use
complete PPE and comply with other OHS at the project site. Immediately
provide assistance if there are victims to reduce the risk of disability. |
Major injury |
Local damage |
Minor effect |
Major impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
|||
Terjadi
human eror pada saat pengoprasian boom |
Posisi
boom berubah dan berakibat fatal karena beban terguling |
Multiple fatalities |
Extensive damage |
Major effect |
National impact |
5 |
3 |
High |
Operator yang mengoprasikan crane haruslah telah bersertifikasi dan fokus saat
bekerja. Pengoprasian harus sesuai dengan standar awal yang telah direncanakan. Gunakan APD lengkap untuk mengurangi resiko cidera parah apabila accident terjadi.
|
Minor injury |
Minor damage |
Local effect |
Limited impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
||
Boom broken |
Multiple fatalities |
Extensive damage |
Major effect |
National impact |
5 |
3 |
High |
Operators who
operate the crane must be certified and focused when working. The operation
must be in accordance with the initial standards that have been planned. Use
complete PPE to reduce the risk of severe injury if an accident occurs and
immediately provide assistance if there are victims. |
Minor injury |
Minor damage |
Local effect |
Limited impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
|||
Loss on costs
due to temporary stoppage of the project |
No/slight injury |
Local damage |
No/Slight effect |
Major impact |
3 |
3 |
Medium |
Workers or
operators must comply with regulations regarding OHS at the project site and
continue to use PPE in accordance with applicable standards, if there are
victims then immediately provide assistance. Operators who operate must be
professional and certified. |
No/slight injury |
Minor damage |
No/Slight effect |
Limited impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
|||
Injury to
workers until death or Disability to workers or crane operators |
Major injury |
Major damage |
Major effect |
Major impact |
3 |
3 |
Medium |
Use complete PPE
to reduce the risk of severe injury if an accident occurs and immediately
provide assistance if there are victims. |
Major injury |
Local damage |
Minor effect |
Major impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
|||
Hoist
experienced an error due to incorrect operation |
Load is unstable
or even toppled over |
Multiple fatalities |
Extensive damage |
Major effect |
National impact |
5 |
3 |
High |
Operators who
operate the crane must be certified and focused when working. The operation
must be in accordance with the initial standards that have been planned. Use
complete PPE to reduce the risk of severe injury if an accident occurs and
immediately provide assistance if there are victims. |
Minor injury |
Minor damage |
Local effect |
Limited impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
||
Damage to other
TBBM facilities resulting in heavy losses in terms of costs |
Fatality |
Major damage |
Major effect |
Major impact |
3 |
3 |
Medium |
Operators who
operate cranes must be certified to avoid errors in operation. At the time of
operation must follow the signs of work at the project site. Immediately stop
other activities around the project to avoid bigger accidents due to damage
to facilities. |
Major injury |
Local damage |
Minor effect |
Major impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
|||
Workers suffered
permanent injuries and even died |
Fatality |
Major damage |
Major effect |
Major impact |
3 |
3 |
Medium |
Workers or
operators must comply with regulations regarding K3 at the project site and
continue to use PPE in accordance with applicable standards, if there are
victims then immediately provide assistance. |
Major injury |
Local damage |
Minor effect |
Major impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
|||
3 |
Maintenance crane |
Worker hit by
key tools for crane maintenance |
Workers experience
fatal injuries that cause permanent disability to death due to accidents and
work is temporarily stopped so that they experience losses in time and costs. |
Fatality |
Major damage |
Major effect |
Major impact |
3 |
3 |
Medium |
Workers or
operators must comply with regulations regarding K3 at the project site and
continue to use PPE in accordance with applicable standards, if there are
victims then immediately provide assistance. |
Major injury |
Local damage |
Minor effect |
Major impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
Worker
electrocuted during maintenance |
Workers suffer
permanent physical injuries and even death |
Fatality |
Major damage |
Major effect |
Major impact |
3 |
3 |
Medium |
Workers remain
focused while performing work and use PPE in full accordance with
regulations. Workers obey the work signs on the project and comply with other
OHS regulations that apply on the project. |
Major injury |
Local damage |
Minor effect |
Major impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
||
The mentality of
other workers was shaken by the accident. |
Major injury |
Major damage |
Major effect |
Major impact |
3 |
3 |
Medium |
Immediately
evacuate the victim and provide immediate assistance to reduce the risk of
severe injury and affect other workers. Conduct a re-briefing on OHS on the
project after an accident occurs. |
Major injury |
Local damage |
Minor effect |
Major impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
|||
Time and cost
losses due to temporary project stoppages |
Fatality |
Major damage |
Major effect |
Major impact |
3 |
3 |
Medium |
Workers or
operators must comply with regulations regarding K3 at the project site and
continue to use PPE in accordance with applicable standards, if there are
victims then immediately provide assistance. |
Major injury |
Local damage |
Minor effect |
Major impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
|||
4 |
Crane unloading |
Worker falls
while dismantling crane |
Workers suffer
permanent physical injuries and even death |
Fatality |
Major damage |
Major effect |
Major impact |
3 |
3 |
Medium |
Workers or
operators must comply with regulations regarding OHS at the project site and
continue to use PPE in accordance with applicable standards, if there are
victims then immediately provide assistance. Workers comply with existing
work signs on the project. Conduct a re-briefing on OHS if an accident occurs
to avoid the same accident from happening again. |
Major injury |
Local damage |
Minor effect |
Major impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
Project was
temporarily suspended and incurred cost losses |
Fatality |
Major damage |
Major effect |
Major impact |
3 |
3 |
Medium |
Workers or
operators must comply with regulations regarding K3 at the project site and
continue to use PPE in accordance with applicable standards, if there are
victims then immediately provide assistance. |
Major injury |
Local damage |
Minor effect |
Major impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
|||
Additional counterwight fell during operation |
Damage to other
facilities at TBBM |
Fatality |
Major damage |
Major effect |
Major impact |
3 |
3 |
Medium |
Workers or
operators must comply with regulations regarding K3 at the project site and
continue to use PPE in accordance with applicable standards, if there are
victims then immediately provide assistance. Operation must be in accordance
with the planned standards.. |
Major injury |
Local damage |
Minor effect |
Major impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
||
Workers suffer
semi-permanent to permanent injuries or workers die |
Fatality |
Major damage |
Major effect |
Major impact |
3 |
3 |
Medium |
Immediately
evacuate the victim and provide immediate assistance to reduce the risk of
severe injury and affect other workers. Conduct a re-briefing on OHS on the
project after an accident occurs. |
Major injury |
Local damage |
Minor effect |
Major impact |
2 |
3 |
Low |
From the results of the analysis in the table above,
namely the hazards of the tangka lifting process in the tangka X construction
project at TBBM Tanjung Priok,
several medium and high value risks were found. The risk assessment in this
analysis process is in accordance with the existing assessment requirements.
This risk identification is carried out to anticipate problems on the project
and analyze the actions that must be taken if the
risk occurs, so that if in the process of running the project the risk occurs
it will not have too much impact. The risks identified in the table above are
high-value risks that must be prevented as well as possible. From the analysis
results, there are 8 risks that can occur on the project. Risk management
guidelines should be made with the aim of being easy to understand and
understand so that the application in the field can run optimally.
Conclusion
The implementation of Risk Management helps companies to
manage risks well where the risks are identified and assessed. In the risk
analysis, there are 8 risks that can occur in the project which are considered
to have a high risk impact. From the analysis results, there are 5 risks with
moderate levels and 3 risks that are of high value. Using the application of
PMBOK in risk analysis can make risk management guidelines easier to understand
and understand but still detailed in the analysis process which can help smooth
the project being implemented. Therefore, the application of the Project
Management Body of Knowledge in the project world is very calculated. Because
as we know PMBOK can help to plan, organize, and improve from every aspect
within the scope of the world of construction projects. There are 4 ways used,
namely rejecting (avoid), reducing (reduce), accepting (accept), and sharing
(share). Mostly, companies take action to reduce risks to reduce the negative
impact arising from these risks. The
implementation of Risk Management can help companies to improve non-financial
performance where the main goal is to meet consumer needs. By measuring the
existing risks, the company will know whether the existing risks are classified
as high / medium / low risk and then the company will be able to manage risks
based on their priority level first.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Aditya, O., & Naomi, P. (2017). Penerapan manajemen
risiko perusahaan dan nilai perusahaan di sektor konstruksi dan properti. Esensi:
Jurnal Bisnis Dan Manajemen, 7(2), 167–180.
Airmic, A., & IRM, A. (2002). A risk management
standard. AIRMIC, ALARM, IRM.
Boulton, R., Libert, B., & Samek, S. (2000). Cracking
the Value Code: How Successful Businesses are Creating Wealth in the Economy.
Wiley.
Boynton, W. C., & Johnson, R. N. (2005). Modern
auditing: Assurance services and the integrity of financial reporting. John
Wiley & Sons.
Brett, J., Green, D., & Moran, A. (2011). Managing risk
in community services: a preliminary study of the impacts of risk management on
Victorian services and clients.
Creswell, J. W., & Creswell, J. D. (2017). Research
design: Qualitative, quantitative, and mixed methods approaches. Sage
publications.
Firgianto,
P., & Djati, S. P. (2020). Analisis Risiko Pengadaan Tanah Untuk Eksplorasi
dan Eksploitasi Minyak dan Gas Bumi (Studi Kasus: PT. Pertamina EP-Paku Gajah
Development Project). Jurnal Manajemen Risiko, 1(1),
93-126.
Luri, H., & Rinawati, D. I. (2019). Analisis Risiko
Keselamatan dan Kesehatan Kerja Dengan Menggunakan Job Hazard Analysis (Studi
Kasus Pt. Pertamina Ep Asset 4 Field Cepu). Industrial Engineering
Online Journal, 8(1).
Stackpole, C. S. (2013). A User’s Manual to the
PMBOK Guide. John Wiley & Sons.
Tavan, F., & Hosseini, M. (2016). Comparison and
analysis of PMBOK 2013 and ISO 21500. Journal of Project Management, 1(1),
27–34.
Wirandaru, A. (2023). Konstruksi Realitas
Pemberitaan Kebakaran Depo Pertamina Plumpang pada Tayangan Berita Youtube
Kompas TV Periode 07-09 Maret 2023.(Construction Reality Reporting of The
Pertamina Plumpang Storage Fire on Kompas TV Youtube News Shows For The Period
Of 07-09 March 2023). Universitas 17 Agustus 1945 Surabaya.
Wibowo, A. A. (2019). Analisa risiko keselamatan kerja pada
explorasi minyak. Jurnal Baut dan Manufaktur, 1(1),
57-68.
Yakub, M., & Phuspa, S. M. (2019). Manajemen Risiko
Kebakaran pada PT Pertamina EP Asset 4 Field Sukowati. J Ind Hyg Occup Heal,
3.
Copyright holder: M. Fanshurullah Asa, Yessy Rama Natalia Pakpahan, Okfi Risa Sabila (2024) |
First publication right: Syntax Literate: Jurnal Ilmiah Indonesia |
This article is licensed under: |