Syntax Literate: Jurnal
Ilmiah Indonesia p�ISSN: 2541-0849 e-ISSN: 2548-1398
Vol.
7,
No.
8,
Agustus 2022
NEW WAVE OF
MARKETING IN POLITICS CASE STUDY: SUCCESS OF MILLENNIALS IN DPRD DKI JAKARTA IN
2019 - 2024 LEGISLATIVE ELECTION
Fauzan
Fadel Muhammad, Yudo Anggoro
School
of Business and Management Institut Teknologi Bandung, Indonesia
Email: [email protected],
[email protected]
Abstract
An interesting phenomenon occurred in a remarkably effective and efficient
shift in campaign strategy carried out by young millennial parliamentarians who
won the 2019 DKI Jakarta legislative elections by controlling the parliamentary
seats of the DPRD DKI Jakarta by 30%. Millennials are the majority community
group of DKI Jakarta residents who actively use social media. The young
generation of DKI Jakarta millennials is the target of Potential Market
(Voters) by young legislative candidates as Segmentation, Targeting, and
Positioning Marketing in conveying the concept of their work program to win the
election and win the hearts of the grassroots community in the 2019 DKI Jakarta
Legislative Election and be able to beat the senior incumbent politician with
experience in politics. The research methodology used with a qualitative and
quantitative research approach, which carries out a primary research approach,
by distributing questionnaires using random sampling techniques. Furthermore,
this research also conducted direct interviews with young legislators who won
the 2019-2024 Legislative Election. The quantitative research such as external
analysis and internal research by carrying out approaches through Benchmarking
analysis and PESTEL Analysis. As well as internal analysis with the C12 New
Wave Marketing approach and VRIO Analysis. From the results of studies that have
been carried out, it is indicated that the implementation of Strategic New Wave
Marketing by implementing and formulating the 12C implementation that
prioritizes New Wave Value can form a distinctive personal brand of a
politician who can form bonds with grassroots communities in their chosen area.
Keywords: New
Wave Marketing, 12C, Election, Branding, Popular, Campaign, political marketing
Introduction
The 2019 Legislative Election in Jakarta is a
phenomenal year in politics due to the rise of young people/millennial�s
participation in the Jakarta legislative election. Millennials, often defined
as Generation Y, are a group of people born after Generation X, born from the
1980s-2000s, aged below 40. and nearly 30% of elected people in the election
are millennials. This paper will examine how marketing strategy aligns with
success in politics. It can be seen, that some research has been done by
government (BPS) or private sector of statistics research and the result showen
that DKI Jakarta have a big population of younger people from 15-49 years old
and is primarily citizens of the middle and upper economy class and more than
50% active as social media in their daily activities life. This will impact how
the marketing strategies will differ compared to other provinces.
Literature
Review
New
wave marketing
The phenomenon of New Wave Marketing is a new paradigm
approach to communicating communally through digital channels and achieving
strategic coverage and new marketing tactics to deliver optimal value to consumers
in the era of digital connectedness. In practice, the principles of Legacy
Marketing may still be applied to some extent. However, at the same time, it
needs to redefine marketing strategies and tactics to become more horizontal in
this New Wave era (Kottler et al., 2017: 48). The young politicians use the New
Wave Marketing strategy. They use the internet as their communication channel
platform. In the era of horizontal communication, it makes fewer barriers to
equality for differences between young politicians and their constituents or
can also be referred to as an audience that is now both equal. The Political
campaign will focus on high exposure and low capital expenditure programs. With
the shift in strategy and the development of new wave marketing technology that
uses the internet platform, the low budget high impact pattern is very likely
to be implemented (Musi, 2017: 96).
Image
Image theory is an
alternative to classical decision theories based on subjective expected
utility, propounded by Lee Roy Beech (Beach, 1990), quoted from Margarita
I�oraitė. (2018) research studies. According to Beach, expected utility
models of decision-making do not match real-world processes. Studies of
actual managerial decisions show that decisions are rarely based on explicit
cost/benefit calculations.
Brand Image
When building a personal
branding for politician, it is essential to think about the brand image because
customers' emotions and perceptions refer to brand image. (Yuan et.al., 2016;
Lahap et al., 2016). Customers like to purchase online of famous brands, and
the company's brand image has a good impact on customer buying decisions (Keller,
2013; Lee and Tan, 2003).
Brand Image can reflect
the customer's thoughts and feelings about the brand. (Roy and Banerjee, 2007).
According to Peter & Olson (2000), brand image is consumer perception and
preference for the brand. It is also reflected by various brand associations
that exist in consumer memory. Although brand associations might occur in
various forms, they can be differentiated into performance associations and
imagery related to brand attributes and advantages.
Decision to purchase/vote
According to the buying
decision process theory of Kotler, Kartajaya, Huan, and Liu (2012), after the
final purchase decision has been made, another important job of marketers has
just begun. At the final stage of the purchase decision-making process, shown
in Figure 1, which is post-purchase behavior, customers evaluate their
experience from the purchase they have made to determine whether they should
revisit the stores or repurchase the products and services (Ratasuk, 2019).
Therefore, to achieve sustainable success, businesses should develop customer
repurchase intentions.
Conceptual Framework
The internet is currently
a basic human need, including in Indonesia. The growth of internet use in
Indonesia is getting higher daily to access the internet, which is currently
more inclined to access using platforms (Fikri, 2018).
Communication through
the internet platform enters all aspects of life. It is not left behind until
it penetrates the realm of political communication between politicians and the
audience (electoral), with growing opportunities for young politicians to get
attention and come to the fore with communication strategies and campaigns for
young politicians. It is essential to develop a conceptual framework to analyze
scientific research on the success of the campaigns of young politicians who
won in the 2019 election for the DKI Jakarta electoral district, which obtained
30% seats in the DKI Jakarta DPRD parliament.
Research
Methodology�
The research will use quantitative and qualitative
methods in this scientific presentation effort. This method is used to describe
research questions scientifically based on valid theoretical arguments and
marketing strategy literature. To reveal the success of the marketing strategy
of young politicians in the parliamentary elections in the 2019 DKI Jakarta
Legislative Election, compared to senior politicians who failed. The
quantitative method is applied in this scientific study, using data from large
enough units. Data is collected through interviews, either using open
interviews or submitting closed questions, commonly referred to as Scala
Questioners, as primary data. This method will be implemented by conducting
interviews with both the success team and the campaign team from senior
politicians and young politicians, in their efforts to win the hearts of
voters, and also distributing closed-ended questionnaires to the people.
External Analysis
PESTEL analysis was first proposed by Aguilar in 1967
as a model to analyze the influence of the environment, both external and
internal Political, Social Economic Technology
and Legal Factors. It is clear from the analysis that the Indonesian
nation has a long history and cannot be separated from its youth, who are
directly involved and participate in physical struggles and political diplomacy
to seize and fill this independence. Our nation allways facilitates and gives the
rights of youth to get involved in politics as enshrined in the 45 Constitution
and Pancasila, especially the fourth principle. in Political factors and Legal
factor. From social factors & economic factors, the common thread that can
be drawn is that, because a young man's conscience is still "idealist
& pure", they are involved in conveying and voicing the voice of the
people they represent. Furthermore, in the current era, the technology factor
makes it easier for young politicians to voice their generation to represent
and express themselves with more effective and efficient communication channels
through the New Wave Marketing Strategy.
Benchmarking
Senior Politician Vs Young Politician
The benchmarking
analysis results have proven that senior politicians make less effort to use
social media as their news media and social media as a tool to expose their
branding, so grass root citizens can recognise them
and vote for them because people know them very well. And young politicians
understand the benefit of social media as media tolls become a media darling.
Internal Analysis
STP Analysis
STP analysis is
important in determining the market strategy that will be planned and
implemented. Based on the geography of DKI, Jakarta is the nation's capital. It
is the largest and most populous metropolis in Indonesia, meaning that the
complexity of life for the people of DKI Jakarta is very dynamic. Therefore,
society needs a figure who can provide the best solution to the problems. They
face. This STP analysis to analyze New Wave Marketing becomes a little blurry
to determine the STP brand because the implementation of the New Wave Strategy
uses 12C and no longer applies the STP strategy.
Segmentation to Communisation:
The political candidate
develops a community that binds the informal community together. This bond is
related horizontally between the politician and the community and interacts
with each other, and this bond becomes very close like brothers and mutually
support each other. As we can see from William, the PSI Political party
candidate has 50,700 followers on four social media applications. This is quite
significant with the votes he won in the 2019 election.
Targeting to
Confirmation:
With communication
between political candidates and consumers established in the community, if the
candidate wishes to do branding, community members must confirm it because they
can decide and accept whether the branding can be done.
Positioning to clarification:
Community members
(customers) can assess and clarify the positioning that the manufacturer has
promised. From social media accounts owned by young politicians who won the
2019 DKI Jakarta DPRD elections, they could clarify that their aspirations and
problems were represented and could be conveyed directly to young politicians
to be fought for in parliament.
VRIO
Analysis
This framework is used
to analyze and assist companies in understanding the company's internal
resources and capabilities to compete in market competition to survive and be
sustainable in tight competition. It uses four questions related to value,
scarcity, imitation, imitation, and the company's ability to identify the value
of the resources needed by the company and capabilities that have the potential
as a competitive advantage related to the competitors (Barney, 2002).
From VRIO Analysis shows
that young politicians who sat in the DKI Jakarta DPRD and won the 2019 general
election already have good personal branding to become the top of mind of the
voting community. It is a significant essential capital for a young politician
to have. After being analyzed using the VRIO approaches, we can see that the
young politicians who won the 2019 DPRD DKI Jakarta elections have a great
support system. However, their sustainability in the Political World still has
to be tested and seen in their career development because the souls of young
people are still young and must be able to prove themselves so they can achieve
the expected performance of the voters, they can have positive values from the
community (minimum gap). �
Root Cause Analysis
In Root Cause Analysis,
several stages must be carried out to analyze the cause and effect of a case
being studied, including several stages: defining the problem, conducting root
cause investigations, submitting an action plan, and implementing the action
plan and monitoring.
Create Action Plan
They are illustrated in
the Fishbone diagram above. In the concept of the popularity triangle, Senior
politicians often ignore the importance of branding management and marketing
communication which are maintained regularly and continuously to keep the
personal branding of these politicians at the top of mind of the grassroots
community.
Media Darling
At this stage, it is
clear that senior politicians are significantly less and even keep a distance
from the media, which is very different from young politicians who consider
social media and social services to be a part of their lives. This media has
two channels, namely social media and news.
Territorial Base Senior
politicians do not understand the importance of market mapping, read the
demographics and geography of the people who will be represented, and keep
their distance from the people they represent.�
This is different from young politicians with their style who can blend
in with the grassroots community and collaborate directly by creating communal
Conclusion
External Analysis
Based on the PESTEL
analysis that uses proven that young politicians still have a place and
sympathy for potential voters because they are considered idealistic,
energetic, and sincere in fighting for and voicing the aspirations of the
people of DKI Jakarta. Young people can interact with their voters in
real-time. Their also can calculate the market power represented in this topic
as actual voters. With the New Wave Tactic & New Wave Value approach, it
effectively won DKI Jakarta legislative election. From the benchmarking
analysis carried out between senior politicians and young politicians, This is where the shortage of senior politicians is getting
more protracted and more distant from the grassroots community as a result of
maintaining their image as members of parliament. A millennial politician who
has been able to win the hearts of voters (market) in the 2019 election still
has many shortcomings, including a track record & very minimal political
communication. However, the community provides the opportunity for the nation's
next generation to have a career in politics and provide maximum results to
fight for the people's voice so that in the future, more millennial politicians
are predicted to take part as members of parliament.
Internal Analysis
From the analysis
results, these young politicians no longer use it but prioritize the New Wave
Marketing Strategy approach with the application of 12C. The millennial
politician, the millennial generation, and the Gen Z generation are very
familiar with contemporary technology, such as social media. Those with minimal
campaign and political costs try to use the New Wave Strategy in building their
political communication. Build an emotional bond with its potential market by
utilizing communization based on friendly horizontal interaction and mutual
support.
The VRIO analysis results prove
that the approach used by millennial politicians in DKI Jakarta using the New
Wave Strategic Marketing method is incredibly effective. As evidenced by the
STP analysis, the electability level of millennial politicians is the essential
capital to be liked and recognized from an early stage. The steps they use are
12C so that not only efficient millennial politicians communicate, but work
programs from the co-creation of followers and horizontal interactions followed
by communal activation can solidify New Wave Tactics & New Wave Values.
These millennial politicians won legislative elections in DKI Jakarta in 2019
Recommendation
From the results of this
study, this paper wants to provide recommendations for further research to
examine more deeply related to the phenomenon of the millennial politician's
victory in the 2019 legislative election in Jakarta; 1. This research is too
generalization on the object of research is too general, not specific in the
case of Marketing Strategy Winning a specific Candidate so that the research
can have more in-depth analysis. 2. The generalized research and a minimal
research period, we cannot explore more deeply than a politician studying
Personal Branding marketing strategies that we can take lessons. 3. The
research point of view can also cover Media exposure, which is not only Social Media, because we know that not 100% of Indonesians
use online media, but channels. Another conventional communication participates
in building the fame and popularity of a politician to be liked by the public.
4. The research scope is minimal. Suppose the research sample could be larger
or include a sample study representing the Indonesian people. In that case, the
study results will be more representative, or if further research is carried
out with different demographics and geography of the community. The research
results will show fascinating results, enriching and deepening the literature
on the study of New Wave Marketing Strategy, which is still very minimal.
Implementation
Plan
The research results
provide evidence, and it acts as a reference for applied planning that can be
used to win a politician with the New Wave Marketing approach. Anyone who wants
to get involved in Practical Politics, based on the described support system so
that a politician has Fame and Popularity to have a high 'like' as a
significant essential capital to achieve electability, there are several things
that need to be considered. Personality Branding
Track Record for Young
Politicians who have just entered into practical politics in 2019, The New Wave
Marketing Strategy approach one of better one tools to implementing becouse it
efective and efficien. Furthermore, senior politicians must follow this step so
as not to be eroded by technology and time.
Competency, young politicians are
expected to continue to strive to improve their insights in Politics,
Communication, and other Branding. Therefore, they can become more reliable and
more established politicians with good competence and can fight for the
aspirations of the grassroots community with all their heart and soul, which
aims to prosper the community with broad insight.
Personal Branding, With
the implementation of 12C in New Wave Strategic Marketing, politicians can form
Soul Character & Care from the results of horizontal communication interactions
without having to build distance with grassroots communities. Furthermore, with
a personal touch from Communal Activation carried out from Co-Creation, which
was built with the community, became the marketing coverage area.
Media Darling, from this
12C approach, politicians can make the news or even create news information
that can be covered by the media, either from the controversial approach or
positive news. Especially from the communal activation, this was confirmed by
the followers.
Popular, the politician
must be liked by the public as the market share. With the implementation of New
Wave Marketing, a politician can learn the character of his territorial base
community from the level of likes. This can be built by developing horizontal
communication and Co-Creation and implemented in Communal Activation, whose
goal is the acquaintance of a politician in one area, Territorial Base
election.
Territorial Base, with the
application of 12C in the New Wave Marketing Strategy approach, political costs
can be minimized. They can easily do zoning to form Communization. There will
be a strong bond between its members, and they will support each other because
they have the same vision and mission in a community or community.
����������������������������������������������� �Systematic
Communisation�
From the diagram above,
it is formed to build a systematic communization to absorb and channel the
aspirations of the grassroots community by directly involving community members
who want to join up to the minor level in the RT environment as a volunteer
team. Then together with these coordinators and volunteers, confirm to be
actively involved in all social activities that will be made. The coordinators
and volunteers have clarified the vision and mission that will be developed by
doing co-creation together. These communal activations include making Ramadhan
Bazaars and Ramadhan Gathering in the surrounding environment, waste management
program, community service, and joint activities at ta'lim majlis. This
activity will make it easier for young politicians and grassroots communities
to carry out conversations and interactions horizontally, intensely, and
closely.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Aaker,
D. A. (1991). Managing Brand Equity. New York: The Free Press. [15]
Alexandra
matahekumual, Mariel., 2021 Propose social media marketing strategy for a new
fashion brand (case study convy wear). School of Business and Management,
Institute Teknologi Bandung.
Andreas
Simorangkir, Dean., 2018Policy evaluation on Indonesia mineral and coalmining
safetymanagementsistem. School of Business and Management, Institute Teknologi Bandung.
APJII,
BULETIN (2020); Survei Pengunaan
Internet APJII 2019 � Q2 2020adakenaikan 25,5 jutapenguna internet baru di RI
Bastos,
W., and Levy, S. J. (2012). A history of the concept of branding: practice and
theory. Journal of Historical Research in Marketing, (4)3, 347-368.
Beach,
L. R. (1990). Image Theory: Decision Making in Personal and Organizational
Contexts. (Wiley Series in Industrial and Organizational Psychology.
Chichester, West Sussex, UK: John Wiley & Sons. [12]
Bivainienė,
L., and �liburytė, L. (2008). The Brand Image As
An Element of Brand Equity Socialiniaityrimai/Social
research, (12)2, 22-31.
Bramantika,
Indra., 2021 Supply chain finance as Pt Bank KaryaTBk competitive advantage
strategy. School of Business and Management, Institute Teknologi
Bandung.
Čere�ka,
B. (2004). Reklamosteorijairpraktika. Vilnius.
Černikovaitė,
M. (2011). Prekės�enklovertėsmatavimomodeliai.
Socialiniųmokslųstudijos/ Societal studies, (3)3, 967�981.
Chen,
C., & Tseng, W. (2010). Exploring customer
based airline brand equity: Evidence from Taiwan. National Science
Council (NSC), 24-34.
DR Nany
Suryawati, (2020) HakAsasiPolitik Perempuan, ideas Publishing.
Erdem,
T., &Swait, J. (2004). Brand credibility, brand consideration, and choice.
Journal of Consumer Research, 31(1), 191-198. https://doi.org/10.1086/383434
Fikri,
A. (2018). Sejarah Media Transformasi, Pemanfaatan Dan Tantangan. Malang: Ub Press
Fishbein,
M (1967) Attitude and the prediction o f behaviour Readings in attitude theory
and measurement, New York Wiley
HanandhyasAnindita.,
2021 Marketing Strategy for new upcycling fashion brand throught media platform
(case study: Kawan) School of Business and
Management, Institute Teknologi Bandung.
Hanaysha, Jalal
Rajeh 2017 An examination of the factors affecting consumer�s purchase decision
in the Malaysian retail market DRB-HICOM University of Automotive Malaysia,
Pekan, Malaysia
HendrisaRachmanda,
Jordi., 2018 Social media content exploration for increasing customer
engagement. School of Business and Management, Institute Teknologi Bandung.
Howard,
J A &Sheth, J N (1969) A Theory o f Buyer Behaviour, New York John Wiley
& Sons, pp 83-114
Copyright
holder: Fauzan
Fadel Muhammad, Yudo Anggoro
(2022) |
First
publication right: Syntax Literate:
Jurnal Ilmiah Indonesia |
This article is
licensed under: |